- Music
- 16 Nov 26
Becoming U2: "There was a story here that needed to be told"
In Becoming U2, Brian O’Connell has captured an extraordinary moment in Irish music – when, as part of a 1978 band competition in Limerick, a four-piece from Dublin played their very first gig as U2. The author discusses with Hot Press the significance of that fateful night – and the detective work that went into bringing this fascinating story to life.
Blink and you might miss it – but there is a plaque on Shannon Street in Limerick, marking what Adam Clayton has described as “the exact point of becoming U2.”
Erected by Limerick Civic Trust, the green plaque hangs outside what was once the Stella Ballroom. Although the site is now better known for its bingo, it was here, on March 18, 1978, that the Dublin band, previously known as The Hype, performed officially as U2 for the very first time, as part of the Pop Group ‘78 competition.
Facing off against bands from across the country – for the top prize of £500, as well as “a recording test where suitable by CBS Records” – U2 were ultimately crowned the overall winners. From there, they went on to change the course not only of Irish music, but of popular music right across the world.
Brian O’Connell – who has authored numerous books – was among those involved in organising the plaque.
“Nothing had ever been marked or celebrated in Limerick about the event,” he recalls. “There were various stories going around as to what had happened – and some people didn’t even believe it had happened. I thought we should address that once and for all!”
Soon afterwards, Brian set out to gather as much information as he could about the event – with his extensive research ultimately taking shape as a fascinating new book, Becoming U2.
“I had read U2 by U2, which Neil McCormick co-ordinated, and I was impressed by the remarks from the band members, as to how important winning the competition in Limerick was,” the author reflects. “That, to me, suggested that this was worth doing.
“I had read a lot of the other books about the band’s history, and there seemed to be a huge gap around the details of this particular event,” he adds. “What sort of a competition was it? How many entered? What was it like on the day? Was there agreement that U2 were the best band – or might that have been a source of contention? I felt there was a story here that needed to be told.”
DIVIDE IN THE AUDIENCE
There were challenges along the way, of course – such as tracking down the bands that U2 had competed against at Pop Group ‘78. But Brian notes that securing an interview with one of the judges at the competition, Jackie Hayden of CBS Records (who would also go one to write for Hot Press), marked a crucial breakthrough moment.
“His views were very important,” Brian remarks. “He gave very detailed explanations as to why they won. They were doing a lot of things that somebody like him, working in a record company, was looking for. They were producing their own music. They had a sound that was original, and different. But what did everyone else feel? That was the intriguing part.”
The more people Brian spoke to, the deeper the intrigue became.
“Informally, people who were at the event were saying that the verdict was far from unanimous. My curiosity was piqued. I had to find out more.”
Brian himself didn’t start out as a U2 obsessive.
“But in doing the book, I’ve listened to a lot of U2 music,” he adds. “And when you do that, you understand the scale of what they have achieved musically, particularly The Edge, who is a true original. And, of course, Bono is such a larger than life personality.”

There isn’t a lot of material available from 1978, by which we might retrospectively check how raw or unprepared U2 might have sounded at the time. However, in its special picture sections, the book includes exclusive shots from the band’s first ever TV appearance, on RTÉ’s Youngline, which took place the same year as the Limerick competition.
“They played ‘Street Mission’,” Brian elaborates. “Bono gets off the stage at one point, and there’s a beautiful, tuneful musical interlude with just Adam and The Edge, with The Edge doing this skilful picking. And this is a song they’ve composed themselves.”
You might assume that rumours that they were rubbish on the night were exaggerated. Then again, Brian was fascinated by the extent to which many observers – including rival musicians – still wanted to talk U2’s performance down. In the end he successfully tracked most of the bands down.
“I think it’s fair to say that there was a big divide in the audience. I wanted to explore that phenomenon from as many perspectives as I could. As a result the book, I think, gives a real sense of just how easily things might have turned out completely differently. And, if they had, on that rainy night in Limerick, the whole story of Irish music might have been completely changed. I think that’s what makes this such a fascinating moment – and a brilliant story that has to be told.”
A BRUTAL DECADE
Becoming U2 arrives at a time when the excitement around the band is at the most intense it’s been in years – with their new album Carnaval de Luz released this month, and a world tour announced for 2027. This year also saw U2 celebrate their 50th anniversary as a band, with a series of surprise events in Dublin.
“Becoming U2 is a lovely reminder of the pure, undistilled excitement we felt at winning the Harp Lager Talent Competition in Limerick all those years ago,” Adam Clayton – who was acting manager of the band at the time as well as playing bass – said recently. “There was a lot of talent in the Stella Ballroom that night and to come away with the top prize of £500 and the opportunity to enter a real recording studio... It was such an important moment for the band and set us on our way. Great memories.”
And in a nicely circular moment, Neil McCormick has also heaped praise on the new book.
“What a wild snapshot of pop history,” he said, “a mad escapade capturing the exact moment a gang of precocious Dublin schoolboys turned into one of the greatest rock groups in the world. Fascinating, thrilling, absurd and hilarious. Essential reading for U2 fans – and anyone who has ever wondered what it really takes to make it in the music business.”
But Becoming U2 offers insights into more than just a fascinating early chapter in U2’s career. It also celebrates the remarkable music culture of Limerick – which continues to spawn thrilling new talent.
“I was born in Dublin, but I have Limerick roots – my father was from County Limerick,” Brian tells us. “But going back to Limerick 50 years ago, for work, there a huge variety of musical activities in Limerick. As Bill Whelan has said, Limerick was beginning to look like a mini Memphis. People were engaging in music very widely at a very young age – there were beat groups, and people were setting up recording studios. Music was, and is, very much part of the culture of Limerick.”
One of the strangest revelations is that Pop Group ‘78 – which was organised as part of the annual Limerick Civic Week – was never repeated again.
“There were a number of new events introduced in the year that U2 won, and at least two of the others went on to be performed for many years afterwards,” he notes. “One was a church choir competition, which continued for another 23 years after 1978. And the traditional music event, which was won by Stockton’s Wing, went on for a number of years afterwards. But the Pop Group event was dropped.”
Why? That is just one other fascinating strand, in a story that tells us so much about this country at the end of the 1970s – a brutal decade in which the seeds were sown that would lead to the emergence of a very different Ireland. In successfully opening a window into our past, Becoming U2 – hailed as “brilliantly told… and very funny” by Dave Fanning – is a truly original addition to what we know about the four-piece that went on to become the biggest rock band on the planet.
• Becoming U2, published by Hot Press Books, is out in paperback and available in Irish shops now. The hardback edition, signed by Brian O’Connell, is available exclusively from shop.hotpress.com now.
RELATED
- Music
- 06 Feb 26
Bob Marley: Revisit his 1978 interview with Hot Press
- Music
- 02 Jun 25
On this day in 1978: Thin Lizzy released Live and Dangerous
RELATED
- Music
- 06 Feb 24
On this day in 1945: Bob Marley was born
- Music
- 02 Jun 23
On this day 45 years ago: Thin Lizzy released Live and Dangerous
- Music
- 02 Sep 22
Keyboard Player with The Atrix Chris Green Has Died
- Music
- 11 May 22
On this day in 1981: Bob Marley died, aged 36
- Culture
- 03 Jun 21
On this day in 1977: Bob Marley and the Wailers released Exodus
- Opinion
- 02 Jun 21