Harvey Weinstein: It's about Misogyny and Complicity Writ Large

For far too long, there has been a conspiracy of silence about the issue of sexual and emotional abuse. Now, that has to change... By Roe McDermott.

As a film critic and a feminist, I’ve felt pressure to write and talk about the Harvey Weinstein case – the seemingly unending, still unfurling accounts of his systematic sexual harassment and abuse of women.

Many of those offering these opportunities have asked me to explore the phenomenon of sexual harassment in the workplace, and how Irish women can protect themselves in their professional lives. I’ve been involved in conversations where the message has been to tell women to look for support from employers, HR departments and employment tribunals.

The problem is, the Harvey Weinstein affair isn’t about sexual harassment in the work place. This is about misogyny, period. To limit our conversations to sexual harassment in the workplace, is to ignore the larger culture that enables and emboldens sexual abusers in every area of life – the workplace only being one facet of that.

Limiting our discussion of sexual harassment to the confines of the workplace also means that, legally and culturally, women aren’t offered support when they are sexually harassed within a very particular workplace setting.

SEXUALLY HARASSED

This gap in our understanding of how to deal with sexual harassment is clear in the case of Harvey Weinstein. The women he harassed, abused and raped were not his employees; they were women in the same industry, and he was a powerful gatekeeper to opportunities.

As a successful film producer, Harvey Weinstein’s power lies in opening up opportunities for actresses. The women who managed to dodge his advances were denied these opportunities: Rose McGowan, Rosanna Arquette, Sophie Dix, Mira Sorvino, Heather Graham and Ambra Battilana Gutierrez have all spoken about how their careers were negatively impacted after refusing to have sex with Harvey Weinstein, and how he even launched public smear campaigns about some of them to further hinder their career prospects.

But if our understanding of sexual harassment is confined to relationships between employers and employees, or co-employees, addressing sexual predators like Harvey Weinstein, who withhold opportunities for advancement from those who refuse to co-operate, becomes all the more difficult, as the pathways of employment are less clear.

What the Weinstein case reveals is how vulnerable many people are to sexual harassment, and how our idea of being sexually harassed by fellow professionals needs to change. In a time when a huge amount of people’s employment comes from freelancing, start-ups, self-employment and small companies without HR departments, it’s naïve and downright negligent to believe that the so-called “proper channels” cited as handling sexual harassment cases are available to all.

AWFUL AND OUTRAGEOUS

As a journalist who has to freelance to make a living, I have experienced sexual and gendered harassment while working, that has impacted on the atmosphere of my working environment, and my professional opportunities and income.

One example of explicit sexual harassment was when I was about to interview an actor, and the director of the movie he was starring in shouted across a room of PR people and other journalists, “Roe’s a good one, be gentle with her – only use one or two fingers!”

Ideally in that situation, I would have been able to call out the two men involved and leave. However, none of the PR representatives nor journalists present said anything, so my immediate response was to feel that I would be on my own if I spoke up. Maybe no one knew what to do or say. Perhaps one brave person would have sided with me if I had.

On the other hand, complaining could have resulted in me getting left out of further interview opportunities, and thus income, and for what? There was never going to be any legal or even personal recourse against those men. The people in that room who remained silent had already suggested as much. Besides, I also had a deadline to meet and a pay-cheque dependent on me going through with the interview – a pay-cheque I badly needed – and so I carried on. That’s what people tend to do, enabling bullies to keep doing it.

But harassment and complicity can often be more insidious, and all the more pervasive and impactful for it. I was in a relationship which involved constant emotional abuse, physical threats, and unrelenting harassment. When the relationship finally imploded, I left the country, fearing his backlash, and trying to mentally process the abuse that had left me suicidal and suffering constant panic-attacks.

Upon my return, I had a very strong feeling that I was being personally and professionally ostracised. The man who abused me had convinced not only friends, but also friends who were professional contacts, that I was a liar, a drama queen, a “psycho.” My main writing gig with Hot Press was never affected and my editors in the magazine were supportive when I told them about having to change my phone number to quell his constant phone calls. But my other positions as a regular contributor on several shows across different platforms simply disappeared, because a man was able to use his social and professional capital to shut me down, to protect himself. As much as half of my income was gone, as well as many of my professional contacts, and even some of the friends in whom I had confided.

Even now, in my work life, years later, I still frequently enter rooms where other media professionals ignore me because I committed the apparently punishment-worthy crime of being abused by a man.

I don’t think they’ll ever understand how terrified I am of them. How I was made to feel like I deserved what had happened to me, like I was being punished by an entire industry. How the loss of income hugely affected my life. This month, as I prepared to move back home, after living in San Francisco, I cried myself to sleep several nights, scared and already emotionally exhausted by the thought that I might be seeing them all again, these people who – knowingly or otherwise – made my professional life a constant source of anxiety.

Needless to say, many of them are now tweeting, writing and talking about how awful and outrageous this Harvey Weinstein situation is...

HIGH PROFILE CASES

The Harvey Weinstein scandal isn’t about sexual harassment in the workplace. It’s about misogyny and complicity, writ large. It’s about society’s default disbelief of women, and our silence regarding abuse, harassment and sexism. It’s about society’s unfaltering protection of abusive men.

It’s about the fact that Harvey Weinstein didn’t stop because women said no, he didn’t stop because industry types found out, and he wasn’t punished because his friends, peers and co-workers found out. He only stopped because we found out. He only stopped because it was made public. Because his private and professional sphere did nothing – or nothing effective at any rate – to stop him.

It’s about his assistants who sent women up to his hotel room when they knew what was about to happen. His colleagues who silenced women like Rose McGowan when he told them he had raped her. His actor friends like Ben Affleck, who claim they “told him to stop doing that” – but continued to work with him, to publicly support him, to enable him, to empower him. The studio reps and executives who withheld job opportunities from actresses like Rosanna Arquette, Heather Graham and Mira Sorvino, when Harvey told them to, because they refused to sleep with him.

It’s about Bill O’Reilly, Roger Ailes, Donald Trump, Roman Polanski, Woody Allen, Casey Affleck; men who sexually harass and abuse women, and who remain protected, employed, powerful while their victims are silenced and ostracised.

This support isn’t just cultural; it’s economic. Fox News paid $13 million to silence O'Reilly's many accusers, and a paid out $50 million in one single year to protect the late Roger Ailes. So far, we are aware of Weinstein’s companies making payouts to at least eight women who said Weinstein sexually harassed them. Allow me to stress: while women are socially, culturally and professionally destroyed, companies literally pay millions to protect abusive men, letting them know that their abusive behaviour will be supported in every possible way.

But these high-profile cases are only the ones we hear about. We don’t hear about the sexual harassment that women in middle-to-low income jobs face on a daily basis, about how the anxiety, intimidation and wage loss effects them. We don’t hear about women who don’t have the professional support systems to take cases to HR departments, or go to the courts.

We don’t hear about the women so exhausted and defeated by abuse that they just keep their heads down during their work day, praying before they enter a room that they don’t have to face their abuser and all those who supported him.

SEXUALLY EXPLICIT COMMENTS

Sexual harassment isn’t about the workplace. It’s about misogyny and abuse, and our seemingly never-ending tolerance for it. It’s about the fact that many people will tweet and write and tut about Harvey Weinstein, but will stand by and watch abuse when it happens right in front of them.

I’m glad we’re talking about Harvey Weinstein. I’m glad his victims are finally being believed, that they may finally feel supported and believe that they did nothing wrong – they never did.

But I wonder. I wonder after all the news stories have stopped, after the hashtags have moved on, after the conversation has changed, when we’re back to talking about Donald Trump, who was still elected President after boasting that he can “grab women by the pussy.”

I wonder if people will actually step in, the next time they see someone powerful making sexually explicit comments to someone else. I wonder if, when they hear that a man is “creepy”, they’ll follow up to see what exactly that means, and who he could be hurting. I wonder if someone powerful tries to rescind jobs and opportunities from others, someone will ask why. I wonder if a woman says she was abused, people will believe her.

I wish I could hope. But right now, it’s still hard to enter rooms with my head up.

 

Related Articles

Film Review: Breathe

Sentimental sheen deflates power of disability activist biopic.

Read More

Film Review: Murder On The Orient Express

Classic whodunnit remake lacks suspense.

Read More

Film Review: Conor McGregor: Notorious

A fairly uncritical documentary that will please McGregor's biggest fan - himself.

Read More

Film Review: Marjorie Prime

THEATRE ADAPTATION PONDERS MORTALITY, MEMORY AND TECHNOLOGY

Read More

In the new Hot Press: Actor Ezra Miller talks Justice League, ballet and elderly assassins

With the latest DC comic adaptation Justice League due to land on November 17th, Roe McDermott caught up with Ezra Miller to talk about playing The Flash and the training that went into his preparation for the role.

Read More

How Katie O'Riordan and Theo + George are bringing style to sustainability

The Irish brand Theo + George is relaunching this season.

Read More

Film Review: The Killing of a Sacred Deer

Irish actors steal the show in this darkly funny tragi-horror.

Read More

Cillian Murphy sings the Brexit blues as he talks about new film The Party

Irish star Cillian Murphy’s latest movie, The Party, is a fascinating exploration of the current state of British politics.

Read More

Sophie Fiennes: On Grace Jones, Bloodlight and Bami, and documenting an icon

Sophie Fiennes’ new documentary about Grace Jones, Bloodlight And Bami, offers a brilliant insight into the fascinating life and career of a cultural icon.

Read More

Opinion: Where does Hollywood go post-Weinstein?

As the fallout continues from the Harvey Weinstein scandal, thoughts turn to how the harrassment of women in the film industry can be prevented in future.

Read More

Film Review: Brawl In Cell Block 99

Vince Vaughan is superb in this slow-burning grindhouse flick.

Read More

Film Review: The Death of Stalin

Pitch black humour brings the laughs in Soviet-era satire.

Read More

Film Review: Thor: Ragnarok

The latest installment in Thor franchise proves amusing, but forgettable.

Read More

Film Review: Bloodlight and Bami

A documentary about iconic singer, which offers frustratingly little context.

Read More

In the new Hot Press: Cillian Murphy discusses his latest role in Sally Potter's political allegory, The Party

In a rare media appearance, Cork-born actor Cillian Murphy - The Wind That Shakes The Barley, The Dark Knight trilogy - sat down with Roe McDermott to discuss British politics, fatherhood and his darkly humorous new project, The Party.

Read More

Checkmate: Checks and Plaids are Officially Back In for Autumn

With checks and plaids back in favour this autumn, Roe McDermott gives the lowdown on this exciting new trend.

Read More

How designer Melissa Curry created a collection of life-affirming jewellery

Designer Melissa Curry's superb new jewellery collection, Success, has bee embraced by everyone from Saoirse Ronan to Arianna Huffington.

Read More

Film Review: The Glass Castle

Woody Harrelson oozes charisma as a dysfunctional dad in this too-tidy adaptation of Jeannette Walls' 2005 memoir.

Read More

Film Review: The Mountain Between Us

Kate Winslet and Idris Elba charm their way through boring romance flick.

Read More

Film Review: Blade Runner 2049

Visually jaw-dropping and philosophically complex sci-fi sequel simply astounds.

Read More

Film Review: The Ritual

Faltering supernatural thriller has shining moments of psychological horror.

Read More

Film Review: It's Not Yet Dark

A powerful documentary about Irish filmmaker, Simon FitzMaurice's struggle with Motor Neurone Disease.

Read More

Film Review: The Party

Witting drawing room drama acts as sharp social satire.

Read More

Film Review: Home Again

Daughter of Nancy Meyers plays it too safe in directorial debut.

Read More

Film Review: Daphne

Sharply observed character study captures a generation's emotional isolation.

Read More

Film Review: Brimstone

Sadistic frontier thriller is cleverly devised by excessively bleak.

Read More

Film Review: Lego Ninjago Movie

Bright and funny instalment maintains, not elevates, the excellent Lego film franchise.

Read More

Fashion: Red Alert

Having re-emerged on the catwalks of New York and Milan, one particular colour is back with a vengeance this autumn. By Roe McDermott

Read More

Back to the Future: Interview with designer Colin Horgan

Colin Horgan’s hugely imaginative, neon-bright designs have found favour with stars such as Dua Lipa and Lady Gaga.

Read More

Work Experience: Interview with The Work director Jairus McLeary

Jairus McLeary’s new documentary, The Work, is a powerful exploration of a therapeutic programme that’s changing the lives of US prisoners.

Read More

Who wrote Logan Lucky?

Speculation is rife about the identity of the screenwriter behind Steven Soderbergh’s new heist flick, but there is a long history of pseudonyms in Hollywood.

Read More

Film Review: The Work

Raw and intimate doc about therapy in prison explores effects of toxic masculinity.

Read More

Film Review: Patti Cakes

Gritty but high-energy underdog tale about rap launches a new star.

Read More

Film Review: Mother!

Cult director astounds with apocalyptic fever-dream.

Read More

Fashion: Unstoppable X Machine

Inspired by The X Files, Caoimhe MacNeice's latest collection has been worn by screen icons like Juliette Lewis.

Read More

Fashion: Freshers' Chic

Attention students! A few simple revisions of your existing wardrobe will get you As in fashion all year.

Read More

Film Review: Wind River

Icy and insightful crime thriller explores the struggles of indigenous Americans.

Read More

Film Review: The Drummer and the Keeper

Warm film about mental health and friendship proves thought-provoking.

Read More

Student Special: The new wave of cult classic in film

We know the staple youth movies – but students have turned to a new wave of cult classics in recent years.

Read More

Film Review: Una

Fascinating but flawed thriller about the effects of sexual abuse.

Read More

Revolution in the Head: Hot Press speaks to Irish hat designer Margaret O'Connor

Margaret O’Connor’s stunning hat designs have attracted the attention of a wide range of celebrities, from Lady Gaga to Finbar Furey.

Read More

Fashion Column: Patent leather makes a comeback

Read More

Film Review: Detroit

Film about police brutality in 1967 feels exploitative instead of insightful.

Read More

What Female Action Stars Are Fighting Offscreen

For all of the action blockbusters spearhearded by women this summer, actresses in the genre are still struggling to have their work appropriately recognised.

Read More

Film Review: Final Portrait

Witty exploration of the artistic process evokes the absurd profundity of Beckett.

Read More

Film Review: Song To Song

Underwhelming effort from legendary director.

Read More

Film Review: A Ghost Story

Poetic exploration of love, life and existence.

Read More

Film Review: The Farthest

Irish director makes awe-inspiring documentary about space and humanity.

Read More

The Worrying Reaction to Girls Trip's success

Read More

Film Review: Baby Driver

Edgar Wright's crime caper is all car chases and cool tunes, little else.

Read More

Film Review: Land of Mine

Oscar-nominated film uncovers shameful piece of WWII history.

Read More

Fashion: Long Live the King

Natalie King's stylish and innovative designs have marked her out as one of Ireland's most talented young designers.

Read More

Fashion: Putting It Into Neutral

For men, it’s all about staying low-key this season, as neutral tones come roaring into fashion – in a tastefully understated way, of course. By Roe McDermott

Read More

Film Review: The Big Sick

Funny and touching film addresses culture clashes, family dynamics and romance.

Read More

Film Review: Spider-Man: Homecoming

Superhero flick fails to swing into action.

Read More

Cillian Murphy opens up about Dunkirk and his relationship with Christopher Nolan

Irish star Cillian Murphy discusses his excitement about once again working with celebrated director Christopher Nolan, the man behind Inception and the Dark Knight trilogy. Their latest film, Dunkirk, is a powerful account of allied soldiers’ evacuation from France during World War 2.

Read More

The Big Picture: How cinema took on a new political relevancy in the modern age

In the contemporary political climate, many writers and filmmakers have found their work taking on new meaning and relevancy.

Read More

Film Review: Pilgrimage

Excessive violence proves numbing in lacklustre Irish film about faith.

Read More

Film Review: 47 Meters Down

Clever, claustrophobic premise elevates mediocre shark thriller.

Read More

Fashion: Georgia on our Mind

Having moved to Ireland after spending her childhood in Tbilisi, Georgia, Nino Sanaia became fascinated with fashion and is now one of the country's most promising young designers.

Read More

Fashion: Bright Young Things

There's no doubt which colour is dominating fashion this summer, with yellow all the rage on the catwalks. By Roe McDermott

Read More

Film Review: Twice Shy

Powerful Irish indie tackles love, abortion and growing up.

Read More

Disability, Representation, and the Law: the importance of Irish film Sanctuary

New Irish film Sanctuary is groundbreaking in its portrayal of intellectual disabilities – and has had a very real effect on Irish law.

Read More

Film Review: The Beguiled

Remake of lurid Civil War flick needs less manners, more fangs.

Read More

Film Review: Risk

Conflict of interest results in incomplete portrait of Julian Assange.

Read More

Will Communication: Interview with Will Ferrell

Comedy superstar Will Ferrell discusses his latest movie The House, reflects on his time withSaturday Night Live and explains why he'd like to take on some more serious roles.

Read More

Film Review: The House

Promising comedy proves frustratingly uneven.

Read More

Film Review: Halal Daddy

Irish comedy about a Muslim abattoir is well-intentioned but not fully convincing.

Read More

Andrew Garfield's comments about gay men spark backlash

The internet and the LGBTQ community are not too pleased with actor Andrew Garfield after he said that he’s “a gay man right now just without the physical act.”

Read More

Anti-Defamation League Criticizes Jay-Z Over ‘Story of O.J.’ Lyrics

Jay-Z’s recently released album 4:44 has been dominating the headlines, mainly for its personal revelations regarding the rapper’s relationship with Beyonce. However, the album has also stirred up controversy regarding its use of stereotypes, and has been accused of being anti-Semitic.

Read More

Kesha Drops ‘Praying,’ Her First Solo Song in Four Years; New Album Due August 11

Kesha dropped her new song, ‘Praying’, yesterday, and also announced that a new album titled Rainbow is on the way. Kesha has been embroiled in a hideous and oppressive legal battle with her former producer/collaborator Dr.Luke, in which she accused him of sexual assault among other charges. While Kesha managed to release some music and did a small tour last year, the lawsuit largely silenced her for the past three years as she fought for the right to be released from her contractual obligations with Dr.Luke’s label RCA. However, Rainbow will be released under RCA, indicating that she still can’t completely free herself form her former mentor.

Read More

Alec Baldwin Criticized for Portraying Blind Man in Upcoming Film

These days, Alec Baldwin is most likely to be annoying conservatives and Republicans stir with his unflattering (and accurate) impressions of Donald Trump, but the actor has now come under fire from a leading disability rights group.

Read More

Ava DuVernay to make Netflix series about the Central Park Five

Ava DuVernay, director of Selma, The 13th and the upcoming adaptation of A Wrinkle in Time, is set to write and direct a mini-series about the Central Park Five for Netflix. The Central Park Five were a group of teenagers who were wrongfully convicted of assaulting and raping investment banker Trisha Meili in 1989. The trial and publicity was an important event in American history due to the maelstrom of racially charged discourse around crime and punishment that emerged in its wake. Donald Trump took out a full-page advertisement in four of the city’s major newspapers advocating for the return of the death penalty, stating he wanted the criminals “to be afraid”.

Read More

Director Ken Loach speaks out against the right-wing press, supports Jeremy Corbyn

Ken Loach and Paul Laverty made some pointed social commentary while accepting their Crystal Globes at the Karlovy Vary Film Festival on Monday.

Read More

Academy invites record 744 new members in effort to increase diversity

The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences announced this morning that it had invited a record 744 new members to its governing body, including many women and people of colour.

Read More

Andy Serkis' Directorial Debut to Open BFI London Film Festival

Andy Serkis may be best known for his motion-capture performances in film such as the Lord Of The Rings trilogy and Planet Of The Apes, but his directorial debut, Breathe, has been given a huge vote of confidence by a major film festival.

Read More

Spike Lee Directs Music Video Criticising Trump

Director Spike Lee has never been one for subtle work, and his latest project is no exception. Lee directed a video for Stew, the singer-songwriter-playwright, whose band The Negro Problem has released a new song called ‘Klown Wit Da Nuclear Code’ – a pointed commentary of Donald Trump’s presidency.

Read More

The Style Council: Reliving four decades in music fashion

Roe McDermott looks back over the past four decades of music and selects some of the most influential sartorial moments.

Read More

Film Review: Gifted

Warm performances save this cynically formulated drama about child prodigy.

Read More

Film Review: Cardboard Gangsters

Frenetic film about young Irish drug dealers captures the devastation of violence.

Read More

Film Review: Whitney: Can I Be Me?

Glib answers detract from tragic rise and fall story of Whitney Houston.

Read More

Film Review: Wonder Woman

Directed by Patty Jenkins. Starring Gal Gadot, Chris Pine, Robin Wright, David Thewlis. 141 mins. in cinemas now

Read More

Film Review: Berlin Syndrome

Unnerving thriller explores the psychological messiness of confinement.

Read More

Film Review: The Red Turtle

Studio Ghibli's latest is an achingly beautiful tale of man, magic and nature.

Read More

Film Review: After The Storm

Delicately constructed family drama simmers with emotional resonance

Read More

Film Review: My life as a Courgette

Exquisite Stop-motion film subverts what we expect from children's narratives

Read More

Wonder Woman is A Triumph For Gal Gadot

Directed by Patty Jenkins, Wonder Woman is a thrilling, witty and visually sumptuous celebration of truth and justice.

Read More

The Wonder of You - an interview with Wonder Woman

Israeli actress Gal Gadot talks about her joy in playing the iconic role of Wonder Woman – and discusses the character’s status as a feminist hero.

Read More

LA Confidential: the hacking problem in Hollywood

As Hollywood faces another hacking scandal, we ask, can the film industry survive constant cyber attacks- and are we all a little bit to blame?

Read More

Film Review: Snatched

Amy Schumer clowns and Goldie Hawn falters in lazy, casually racist comedy.

Read More

Film Review: I Am Not Madame Bovary

Satire of Chinese bureaucracy is slyly funny but self-indulgent

Read More

Fashion: Blank Generation

It's all about keeping it simple this summer as white makes a comeback on the catwalks.

Read More

Film Review: In View

Caoilfhionn Dunne is incredible in uncompromising portrait of depression

Read More

Film Review: Colossal

Genre-defying dramedy tackles terrifying monsters and toxic masculinity

Read More

Jude Abides: Interview with Jude Law

Hollywood star Jude Law discusses his cracking new historical romp, King Arthur: Legend of the Sword, his fruitful working relationship with director Guy Ritchie, and the film's resonance in the current political climate. Interview by Roe McDermott

Read More
 

Advertise With Us


For information including benefits, key facts, figures and rates for advertising with Hot Press, click below

Advertise

Find us elsewhere