The singer has lashed out at the critic who slated his Gaiety gig.
Chris de Burgh has launched an astonishing riposte to an Irish Times review of his Gaiety Theatre show. The review appeared in the Times last Thursday, and a copy of an email sent by the singer, in response, to the reviewer Peter Crawley, has been seen by Hot Press.
The review contained a generally negative reaction to the gig – one of three sell-out nights, which attracted an audience of over 3,000 to the theatre – and depicted de Burgh in a decidedly unflattering light.
The spat touches on an age-old debate concerning the role of the reviewer. Is there – as artists, managers and promoters often insist – a need, in the context of a review, to reflect what happened at a gig, and to report on what the audience reaction is? Or is a purely subjective response what it’s all about?
“A small man appears,” Crawley wrote, “in suit trousers and a white shirt, giving a little wave, like a businessman happy to have finished a long day of conference calls.
“This man is Chris de Burgh. You may have heard of him. The name alone summons a rush of associations, some of which carry a shudder, few of which fail to draw a smile.
“There is that warbly tenor,” the review continues, “the calling card of the mawkish balladeer (“I have never seen that dress you’re wearing . . . ”) which switches at the faintest invitation into a throaty belt: “DON’T PAY THE FERRYMAN!” There is that haircut, long at the back and wispy up front, entirely unruffled by 34 years in the music biz.
“And of course there is that cringe factor, unalleviated by the man’s apparent earnestness: his slightly tarnished squeaky clean persona, his claims to heal people with his hands, his indelible association with a time of shoulder pads and enormous hair. In short, it’s easy to snigger at de Burgh.”
Clearly stung by the personal nature of much of the comment in the review, de Burgh wrote to Crawley in terms that more than match – and indeed in places far exceed – the reviewer in terms of vituperation. The email includes a bilious sideswipe at Joe Breen, the former rock critic with the Irish Times, who now reviews country and roots music for the paper, and also served for a time as wine correspondent.
(Joe Breen's response, when Hot Press contacted him, was short and sweet: "I'm lucky to be blessed with a sense of humour.")
De Burgh's email to Crawley continues: “Your churlish review is an insult to all those who enjoyed their night out, and in these days of collapsing newspaper sales and an entire new generation on the way who will get their information online, you may be looking for another job sooner rather than later. Your pals in the pub must have loved your review, but it seems that you are universally loathed in the Theatre world; a leading Impresario has described you as ‘puffed up with his own self-importance’, and a much loved and successful actress refers to you as ‘that loathsome little turd’. Great accolades, to be sure.”
Accusing the reviewer of having gone to the show with his mind made up, he goes on: “… to totally ignore what actually happened and launch a personal attack is so transparent that any reader can see that it was pointless even writing it, as you were the only person who attended the show that night who didn't ACTUALLY WANT TO BE THERE!!”
“It was a great gig,” Noel McHale of MCD told Hot Press. “The reaction was amazing – he was getting standing ovations from half way through the show. The band were shit hot, the musicianship was amazing and the production was superb – they did things with the lighting and with special effects that I’d never seen before. Technically, it was brilliant. But none of that was reflected in the review – which doesn’t seem fair or balanced.”
Peter Crawley’ Reflections On The Letter
Peter Crawley told Hot Press that he thinks the problem here is that de Burgh’s public and private personas have become mixed up.
“I sort of felt I could write about Chris de Burgh, this persona, and for it not really to emotionally trouble him. Genuinely, I think – that’s maybe my naivete – that somebody with a career of over 30 years standing will take it in his stride,” said Crawley.
But the Irish Times critic adds that there’s another aspect of de Burgh which may be at the root of this disagreement: “I think there’s a disconnect between how he sees himself and his understanding of what a perception of him might be. You see that in his performance, where suddenly he portrays himself as a rock and roller without fully understanding what rock and roll might be. And bridling against the whole crooner tag, which is a better description of what his music is and what his music was and what it means at a particular time.”
“To be inflexible after so many years makes you a nostalgia act and you have to accept that as part of the package. I guess, not being able to see that, makes him, in my mind, a little bit distanced from the scene – not having a very good outside objective perspective of himself. Or maybe not able to disentangle the idea of Chris de Burgh, the person who is a good father or a nice guy or a good guy to have a drink with, and Chris de Burgh that figure: the guy on the stage, the guy on the album cover, the guy in the video, the singer of those verses. I guess a lot of us never have to handle the idea of a public persona and a private life and I guess maybe you take things personally that aren’t meant personally. And I guess maybe, on my side, I should be better aware that things can be taken personally that aren’t meant that way,” said Crawley.
So, is this just another case of the age old debate about how objective/subjective reviewers can/should be?
“There’s no such thing as complete objectivity. You can’t really have a structuralist reading of a concert! So everything is subjective but must be argued. You have to back up a position. While prejudice isn’t going to help you, you have to take to evidence of the performance and any evidence that’s kind of attached to a persona that’s built up,” said Crawley.
“Obviously, I was surprised that it evidently was so wounding and clearly stuck in his craw. And, you know, you do tend to lose sight of the fact that when you’re talking about a public persona, there’s somebody with a mum and there’s somebody who gets hurt and somebody who is going to take it poorly. But the alternative is criticism which is nothing but unmitigated praise and I don’t think that’s especially helpful either,” he said.
Asked about his reaction on receiving de Burgh’s email, the critic said (with maybe just a hint of irony at times): “If you read it, it’s funny. It’s a little bit – I mean, you do cringe. In fairness, he has written this to be amusing and you’ve got to hand it to him – he’s obviously spent a long time and a lot of effort finding out who I am. That’s almost touching really.”
Crawley mentioned that, though the letter “seems to have circulated rather widely,” he had understood it to be a personal correspondance.
“It was, at least, addressed to me and he did ask to meet. So I wrote back and offered a few times that I’m available to meet him. I haven’t heard back yet but I think the offer stands,” he said.
For the full text of Chris de Burgh’s letter, click here.
The actress celebrated her Irish heritage with a few pints of Guinness and some of her favourite bad jokes, watch the video here.Read More
The hit song, written by Irishman Brendan Graham and Norwegian Rolf Løvland, has become a modern classic...Read More
The Emerson, Lake & Palmer guitarist joins the depressingly long list of musicians we've lost in 2016Read More
Rapper Banks accused the actor of assault at a hotel party.Read More
The full album features covers of Amy Winehouse, Radiohead, Nine Inch Nails and The Rolling Stones.Read More
The pop star talked about broadway, her new music, and kissing Michael Jackson, while still finding time to criticise James Corden's fashion sense.Read More
Fans of only the best classic rock can look forward to tuning into John Clarke’s Biggest Jukebox on Radio Nova.Read More
The documentary will be re-aired December 10, the night of the Nobel prize-giving ceremony.Read More
The success of Caesarean sections since the Second World War has led to a 20 per cent increase in obstructed childbirths, according to new research.Read More
UFC fighter Conor McGregor is the latest name lined up to star in the HBO fantasy drama.Read More
We're excited for May 27.Read More
The sci-fi hit will return for an all-new season.Read More
Harvest 2017 makes its boutique bow next August.Read More
Axl, Duff and Slash are returning to Lord Henry's gaff on May 27th!Read More
The presenter blames disagreements with management for his immediate departure.Read More
Missing out last week on the top spot after Metallica sailed in with Hardwired...To Selfdestruct, Little Mix bagged the Irish Number One today with their fourth album Glory Days.Read More
Stuart Clark was named Journalist of the Year and Niall Stokes was named Editor of the Year at the ceremony held in City Hall last night.Read More
We also get in the Xmas mood with The Melvins & Los Campesinos!Read More
Full details of the cross-border events will be announced next Monday.Read More
The Fab Vinny Hanley favourites are over next July.Read More
Mr. Bergin has already made his way to the fictional seaside town of Red Rock.Read More
Jim Broadbent, James Frecheville, Freddie Fox, Barry Keoghan, Stephen Rea, and Sarah Greene join the cast of the new Irish historical drama starring Hugo Weaving.Read More
Jean-Michel Jarre speaks to Hot Press about working with NSA whistleblower Edward Snowden on a new track.Read More
We delve into the Hot Press archive for an extraordinary interview with the criminal...Read More
The SoCal punk veterans are over next June.Read More
The new video features a summery depiction of high school life in middle America.Read More
Forthcoming Elvis/Johnny Tribute Show will raise funds for Amnesty International's "I welcome refugees" campaign.Read More
The biggest online survey of its kind anywhere in the world, last year’s Global Drug Survey was completed by over 100,000 people from more than 50 countries, with the findings revealing who’s taking what, where, how often and for how much.Read More
Stuart Clark recalls that historic night in Havana...Read More
US President Barack Obama has offered America's "hand of friendship" to Cuba as the Caribbean island mourns the death today of its former leader, Fidel Castro.Read More
It may be winter outside, but our tuneage could not be hotter!Read More
Even Bono can't get tickets to Hamilton.Read More
Roe McDermott speaks to Teyonah Parris about her role in Spike Lee's new film Chi-raq.Read More
Edwin McFee takes you track by track through the best new singles from Alessia Cara and others; with some old favourites to get you into the Christmas spirit. Listen to them now below.Read More
Ireland’s latest international hit movie keeps on racking up the honours in both the US and the UK.Read More
In a wide-ranging interview in the new Hot Press, out tomorrow, November 24, Social Democrats co-founder Catherine Murphy discusses everything from Stephen Donnelly's shock departure from the party to the government’s approach to the Eighth Amendment, as well as airing her views on the contentious issues of our times: euthanasia, drugs, pornography, prostitution and Donald Trump.Read More
We look back at Leonard's remarkable career with the help of friends & musical admirers.Read More
The head of TV3 News was with the station since its launch – and was involved in establishing some of RTE’s biggest rival's key Irish programmesRead More
Gigi Hadid has apologised for impersonating Melania Trump at the American Music Awards, after the model came under fire for being "disrespectful" to the future First Lady of the United States.Read More
The novelist, playwright and short story writer passed away at the age of 88.Read More
Little Steven reckons it was bullying, while his fellow E Street Band-er reckons the attack on Mike Pence was entirely justified.Read More
There was very sad news for everyone in radio in Ireland today, as one of the original stalwarts of independent radio in Ireland Billy McCarthy of WLR passed away after a short illness.Read More
The Dap-Kings leader had one of the sweetest soul voices.Read More
Hot Press is finding out who's taking what, where, how often and for how much with this confidential online survey.Read More
The singer had fallen in his home.Read More
The Committee seem okay about the no-show...Read More
Belfast trio Hot Cops premiered the unnerving video for their new single this week.Read More
His right-hand men and women will be descending on the Brixton Academy in January.Read More
Leonard's son, Adam, has also sent a message to fans.Read More
You can say your tearful goodbyes next June...Read More
Elton John is among those paying his respects to the Wrecking Crew legend.Read More
Turn the volume up and join in!Read More
Ireland sit proudly atop Group D in the European World Cup qualifiers tonight, after a superb performance against Austria in Vienna. Take a bow, goal-scorer James McClean...Read More
“A great poet leaves us but he will stay in our hearts forever,” reflects Antonio Banderas.Read More
The new issue includes an interview with Arrival star Jeremy Renner.Read More
The former Miss Universe Ireland, best selling author and Instagram celebrity takes a stand on many of the big issues of the day – and her outspoken views will doubtless cause considerable controversy.Read More
Watch: 3:30PM UK TimeRead More
Keep your ears out for this Galway-based band!Read More
Happy Election Day, America! And apologies to the rest of the world...Read More
Irish music has lost another of its good guys...Read More
Whether the purchasers get in is an entirely different matter...Read More
Her BBC star is firmly in the ascendent!Read More
It has to be said the CF Reus lads have impeccable taste!Read More
Ryan Tubridy has revealed that Friday's Late Late Show will feature an exclusive Irish interview with Bruce Springsteen in London.Read More
It will be fun, it will be rude, it will be indiscreet!Read More
Them and Elton are in town next June.Read More
It's 20 years later, but nothing's really changed...Read More
His musical peers held the Belfast singer-songwriter in extremely high regard.Read More
The electro-stunner features the voice of Sinéad White.Read More
The Irish indie hotshots are in live action this weekend.Read More
The Black Madonna, Ben UFO, Palms Trax are among the first names to be revealedRead More
Team Hot Press are deeply saddened by the news but, wow, what memories!Read More
Step this way for some serious vocal strangeness...Read More
His June 20, 2017 stop-off could be his last for quite a while...Read More
The referendum will be attached to November 8's Presidential ballotRead More
Her much-anticipated I'm Yours album hits the racks on Friday.Read More
You can help boxing drama, Guard, become a reality...Read More
He's joining Fergus' band Interference for Cork & Dublin gigs next year.Read More
Andy Irvine, Dónal Lunny, Paddy Glackin, Mike McGoldrick & John Doyle are up for the session!Read More
Material new and old will get an airing in January.Read More
Purchasers' names will be printed on tickets & photo ID demandedRead More
The world's biggest indie band had already announced a Glastonbury appearance. Now they are coming to Ireland, as part of a European jaunt...Read More
If it is at all possible, that is! The bard has finally broken his silence on being awarded the Nobel Prize for Literature 2016.Read More
The twice Oscar nominated Irish actress has begun filming in Dorset, under the directorial eye of Dominic Cooke, with Billy Howle as the male leadRead More
The Irish singer-songwriter and member of The Saturdays has revealed that her debut solo album, The Waiting Game, will be released in February 2017.Read More
The Heavy Entertainment Show paves its way for a summer tour dateRead More
The Bow St. Sessions, a collaboration between Jameson and Hot Press, hit Cork last night – and there was a special flavour to the occasion. Michael McGrath-Bryan reports.Read More
Reports are that the iconic LA outfit will begin the European leg of their reunion tour in GAA headquarters in Dublin next summerRead More
The Guinness Cork Jazz Festival is back with one of its most stunning arrays of talent yetRead More
Vertigo Releasing has acquired the US, UK and Australia rights to the cocaine comedy which has grossed over €1m in the Republic of Ireland.Read More
Overall, the results in the three-monthly radio poll were downbeat, and there were some significant losers in the ongoing battle to retain audiences.Read More