The singer has lashed out at the critic who slated his Gaiety gig.
Chris de Burgh has launched an astonishing riposte to an Irish Times review of his Gaiety Theatre show. The review appeared in the Times last Thursday, and a copy of an email sent by the singer, in response, to the reviewer Peter Crawley, has been seen by Hot Press.
The review contained a generally negative reaction to the gig – one of three sell-out nights, which attracted an audience of over 3,000 to the theatre – and depicted de Burgh in a decidedly unflattering light.
The spat touches on an age-old debate concerning the role of the reviewer. Is there – as artists, managers and promoters often insist – a need, in the context of a review, to reflect what happened at a gig, and to report on what the audience reaction is? Or is a purely subjective response what it’s all about?
“A small man appears,” Crawley wrote, “in suit trousers and a white shirt, giving a little wave, like a businessman happy to have finished a long day of conference calls.
“This man is Chris de Burgh. You may have heard of him. The name alone summons a rush of associations, some of which carry a shudder, few of which fail to draw a smile.
“There is that warbly tenor,” the review continues, “the calling card of the mawkish balladeer (“I have never seen that dress you’re wearing . . . ”) which switches at the faintest invitation into a throaty belt: “DON’T PAY THE FERRYMAN!” There is that haircut, long at the back and wispy up front, entirely unruffled by 34 years in the music biz.
“And of course there is that cringe factor, unalleviated by the man’s apparent earnestness: his slightly tarnished squeaky clean persona, his claims to heal people with his hands, his indelible association with a time of shoulder pads and enormous hair. In short, it’s easy to snigger at de Burgh.”
Clearly stung by the personal nature of much of the comment in the review, de Burgh wrote to Crawley in terms that more than match – and indeed in places far exceed – the reviewer in terms of vituperation. The email includes a bilious sideswipe at Joe Breen, the former rock critic with the Irish Times, who now reviews country and roots music for the paper, and also served for a time as wine correspondent.
(Joe Breen's response, when Hot Press contacted him, was short and sweet: "I'm lucky to be blessed with a sense of humour.")
De Burgh's email to Crawley continues: “Your churlish review is an insult to all those who enjoyed their night out, and in these days of collapsing newspaper sales and an entire new generation on the way who will get their information online, you may be looking for another job sooner rather than later. Your pals in the pub must have loved your review, but it seems that you are universally loathed in the Theatre world; a leading Impresario has described you as ‘puffed up with his own self-importance’, and a much loved and successful actress refers to you as ‘that loathsome little turd’. Great accolades, to be sure.”
Accusing the reviewer of having gone to the show with his mind made up, he goes on: “… to totally ignore what actually happened and launch a personal attack is so transparent that any reader can see that it was pointless even writing it, as you were the only person who attended the show that night who didn't ACTUALLY WANT TO BE THERE!!”
“It was a great gig,” Noel McHale of MCD told Hot Press. “The reaction was amazing – he was getting standing ovations from half way through the show. The band were shit hot, the musicianship was amazing and the production was superb – they did things with the lighting and with special effects that I’d never seen before. Technically, it was brilliant. But none of that was reflected in the review – which doesn’t seem fair or balanced.”
Peter Crawley’ Reflections On The Letter
Peter Crawley told Hot Press that he thinks the problem here is that de Burgh’s public and private personas have become mixed up.
“I sort of felt I could write about Chris de Burgh, this persona, and for it not really to emotionally trouble him. Genuinely, I think – that’s maybe my naivete – that somebody with a career of over 30 years standing will take it in his stride,” said Crawley.
But the Irish Times critic adds that there’s another aspect of de Burgh which may be at the root of this disagreement: “I think there’s a disconnect between how he sees himself and his understanding of what a perception of him might be. You see that in his performance, where suddenly he portrays himself as a rock and roller without fully understanding what rock and roll might be. And bridling against the whole crooner tag, which is a better description of what his music is and what his music was and what it means at a particular time.”
“To be inflexible after so many years makes you a nostalgia act and you have to accept that as part of the package. I guess, not being able to see that, makes him, in my mind, a little bit distanced from the scene – not having a very good outside objective perspective of himself. Or maybe not able to disentangle the idea of Chris de Burgh, the person who is a good father or a nice guy or a good guy to have a drink with, and Chris de Burgh that figure: the guy on the stage, the guy on the album cover, the guy in the video, the singer of those verses. I guess a lot of us never have to handle the idea of a public persona and a private life and I guess maybe you take things personally that aren’t meant personally. And I guess maybe, on my side, I should be better aware that things can be taken personally that aren’t meant that way,” said Crawley.
So, is this just another case of the age old debate about how objective/subjective reviewers can/should be?
“There’s no such thing as complete objectivity. You can’t really have a structuralist reading of a concert! So everything is subjective but must be argued. You have to back up a position. While prejudice isn’t going to help you, you have to take to evidence of the performance and any evidence that’s kind of attached to a persona that’s built up,” said Crawley.
“Obviously, I was surprised that it evidently was so wounding and clearly stuck in his craw. And, you know, you do tend to lose sight of the fact that when you’re talking about a public persona, there’s somebody with a mum and there’s somebody who gets hurt and somebody who is going to take it poorly. But the alternative is criticism which is nothing but unmitigated praise and I don’t think that’s especially helpful either,” he said.
Asked about his reaction on receiving de Burgh’s email, the critic said (with maybe just a hint of irony at times): “If you read it, it’s funny. It’s a little bit – I mean, you do cringe. In fairness, he has written this to be amusing and you’ve got to hand it to him – he’s obviously spent a long time and a lot of effort finding out who I am. That’s almost touching really.”
Crawley mentioned that, though the letter “seems to have circulated rather widely,” he had understood it to be a personal correspondance.
“It was, at least, addressed to me and he did ask to meet. So I wrote back and offered a few times that I’m available to meet him. I haven’t heard back yet but I think the offer stands,” he said.
For the full text of Chris de Burgh’s letter, click here.
Here's a few Netflix additions to get you through the rough three day weekend.Read More
The British pop/rock band will play alongside Arcade Fire at Ormeau Park, Belfast on June 13Read More
It was 20 years ago that U2’s legendary PopMart tour hit the road. Here we revisit Hot Press’ Neil McCormick's AAA report.Read More
Two decades after their groundbreaking sonic departure we delve into the archives as Niall Stokes grills the Irish superstarsRead More
Irish indie pop fans have a good reason to smile. After a decade's absence from the tour circuit here, Saucy Monky – fronted by Annmarie Cullen and Cynthia Catania – return with a short run of all-acoustic gigs.Read More
The R n B supergroup are Sin E-boundRead More
The European Parliament Culture Committee wants 30% European content on Netflix and other VoD services in every EU member state.Read More
Pixar's Cars 3 has a new full trailerRead More
The singer-songwriter will release a deluxe 10-CD box set, includes all eight solo albums, plus Butterfly, a newly recorded set, and Rarities, a disc of previously unreleased and rare tracks in June .Read More
Those who like tribute bands are in for a real treat this upcoming May Bank Holiday weekend, as both 'Thin Az Lizzy' & 'Mack Fleetwood' will take to the stage at The Church Bar & Restaurant venue near Jervis St in Dublin between 27-28 AprilRead More
The new edition is published by South Bank Press in paperback and for the first time in e-reading format on Kindle.Read More
Irish film Director Damien O’Callaghan returns with The Gift, an independently financed movie about grief and suicide.Read More
The Norwegian DJ will headline District 8 with a live show Friday, June 16.Read More
23-year old Irish actress Saoirse Ronan will take on the historical role of Mary Stuart in Josie Rourke’s Mary Queen of Scots movie.Read More
The multi-platinum sensation will come to Dublin in September for one night only.Read More
The Swedish electronic quartet return to Dublin on October 31.Read More
Emma Watson, known for her role as Hermione in the Harry Potter-series and more recently for her role as Belle in the Beauty and the Beast-remake, elaborates on the dangers of social media.Read More
The Dublin Sci-Fi Film Festival just revealed that the opening film for for the festival will be Luc Besson’s piece The Fifth Element.Read More
Fresh from their appearance at Levon Helm Tribute Night over the weekend, The Strawhall House Band will return to The Sugar Club on May 1 for the launch of their appropriately titled new album Six Days In May.Read More
Hot Press is celebrating the 20-year milestone of U2’s Pop Mart Tour, highlighting the original 1997 cover featured on the Hot Press’s U2 cover wall.Read More
The actor tells all about portraying Martin McGuinness in director Nick Hamm's new film.Read More
Culture Club was just added to the festival’s line up for July 29.Read More
The pop star isn't exactly thrilled that the story of her life is headed to the silver screen.Read More
Camden’s KOKO club will host some of the best of grime, hip-hop and disco house on the KOKO Burst Stage; featuring artists such as Crazy P Soundsystem, Icarus, Jay Prince, New Gen & Friends, NVOY, Jafaris, DJ Cable and Jonny X.Read More
The Irish folk singer tweeted this morning in opposition to the plans to give ownership of the new €300m taxpayer-funded National Maternity Hospital to the Religious Sisters of Charity – because they own the land on which it is to be built.Read More
The 2017 Baywatch-movie delivers a fourth trailer featuring a cross-dressing Zac Affron, humor and mediocre CGI-fires.Read More
It will go down as the biggest gaffe in the history of the Oscars when Warren Beatty and his co-cost accidentally read out the wrong name for the best picture...Read More
TV stylist Cathy O’Connor and world-renowned fashion blogger Louise Cooney have today been announced as special guests at ‘A Stylish Afternoon Tea’ fashion and beauty event, taking place in the Newgrange Hotel, Navan, Co Meath on Sunday May 14, 2017.Read More
Oscar-nominated director Juanita Wilson's latest film will be available to watch at home this Friday.Read More
The film will focus on Madonna's early career in the 80s, her love life, and her struggles with sexism in the industry.Read More
The South African social activist said, “Please do what artists did in South Africa’s era of oppression: stay away, until apartheid is over.”Read More
Tickets for Oliver's August gig at Custom House Square will be available this Friday.Read More
The British artist and musician will be Ireland-bound this May.Read More
The platinum-certified artist will play a headline show at Custom House Square in August.Read More
Duncan Reid and The Big Heads are touring to support the release of their third album Bombs Away, which is out on May 19.Read More
The indie-folk songwriter's new EP, Attach to Memory will be available May 24.Read More
The legendary musician and producer will play at the Dublin Unitarian Church this Friday.Read More
The original girl power band are reforming.Read More
The singer is set to come to Dublin to debut his new album this monthRead More
Harry Potter In Concert brings the first movie: Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone back to the screen accompanied by a live symphony orchestra.Read More
The event has received support from President Michael D. Higgins and Adi Roche.Read More
Happy Mondays have been added the as headliners for this summer's Bulmers Live at LeopardstownRead More
On May 5, 2017 the New York DJ is coming to Dublin’s Index.Read More
After the sped-up predecessor, the first full trailer for Kingsman: The Golden Circle has arrived.Read More
Good news for Electric Picnic ticket-holders, as the French indie band gear up for a performance there this September.Read More
1980’s Eurovision Song Contest Winner Shay Healy has had his trophy on a glass shelf until recently somebody stole it.Read More
The threat North Korea poses has become very real and by demand of the population, the Japanese government has issued worst-case scenario guidelines.Read More
After reports that Deadpool 2 would arrive in the cinemas in early 2018, it’s been revealed now that the irreverent superhero will be back on the screens in summer 2018.Read More
Amid rumours that he's quitting music after his Divide tour, Ed Sheeran tweeted two words that put the gossip to rest.Read More
Belgian Oscar And The Wolf has finished writing, recording and producing his new album.Read More
Calling all developers and coders - Dublin is to play host to a Ticketmaster Hackathon where the local developer community will be invited to help create the best ticketing experience for fans.Read More
She's over in September to coincide with the release of her Native Invaders album.Read More
The former Presidential candidate will travel to Ireland for the first time.Read More
James Cameron is working on 4 Avatar sequels and each has received a release date. A Facebook post announced December 18, 2020, December 17, 2021, December 20,2024 and December 19, 2025.Read More
Chris Rea will play The Olympia Theatre this December as part of a European tour to celebrate the release of his new album Road Songs for Lovers.Read More
Monroe’s Tavern in Galway continues to provide the best of international, national or local acts for every taste of music.Read More
There was nothing predictable about the outcome of the deliberations of the so-called Citizen's Assembly – but the real question remains how liberal will the laws on abortion in Ireland become?Read More
At 2.30pm this afternoon, the Citizen's Assembly voted by a slim majority to recommend that Article 40.3.3 (known as the 8th Amendment) to the Constitution should be replaced or amended.Read More
The Citizen's Assembly, which was tasked with deliberating on matters to do with the 8th Amendment, has voted comprehensively that a change should be made to the current status quo.Read More
Taking place over three days in May, Music Cork will create a unique opportunity in Ireland to listen to some of the best industry professionals talk about their work and experiences, see the best new talent perform and enjoy plenty of opportunities to network with speakers and delegates over three days of intimate social gatherings and shows.Read More
AeroMobil, a Slovakian tech-company, has presented their commercially available Version 4.0 flying car at the Top Marques Monaco 2017.Read More
The new track can't catch up to "Shape of You", but it has reached number four this week.Read More
Three new video logs have been released. The footage was left behind by crew members aboard the spaceship covenant before they entered cryosleep.Read More
K-Dot debuts one spot from the top with new album DAMN.Read More
Luke 'Ming' Flanagan has told us what happened when himself, Gino Kenny and Vera arrived in this afternoon from Barcelona where she'd obtained medicinal cannabis for her daughter...Read More
She's finally made it through to Arrivals having had the medicine she needs for her daughter, Ava, confiscated...Read More
Body & Soul, which takes place on June 23-25, 2017 in Ballinlough, Co. Westmeath, provides visitors a mix of music, art, food, theatre and more.Read More
Rualie Buaile are among the Irish bands set to be supported by Culture Ireland.Read More
The 90s sci-fi hit is coming back again for a ten-episode run.Read More
HBO released exclusive pictures of the seventh season of Game Of Thrones on their site yesterday.Read More
“3-D THE CATALOGUE” will feature performances from Kraftwerk in some of the leading contemporary art museums in the world.Read More
The new collaboration will create at least two new shows per year, with the first expected to air in 2018.Read More
The one-time plumber from Crumlin makes the list.Read More
As the world came to terms with the loss of Prince, the likes of Lianne Le Havas, Janelle Monáe, Ani Di Franco, Simon Le Bon and former New Power Generation drummer John Blackwell reflected on both the man and the myth. Raiding the archives: Stuart Clark.Read More
Paul Nolan casts a critic's ear over the great man's remarkable career...Read More
The festival, which will take place on the 3rd and 4th June, announces the return of the European Firestone Music Tour with a Battle of Bands.Read More
Scouting For Girls are set to play a 10th anniversary tour with their headline Irish show in the Academy Dublin on November 8.Read More
To celebrate the release of the new album ‘Humanz’ (Fri April 28th), you are invited to the Humanz House Party, an exclusive worldwide listening event...Read More
Accompanied by Gino Kenny & Luke Flanagan, Vera is flying in to Dublin this morning with the banned medicine her daughter, Ava, desperately needs.Read More
What has been billed as the first East West Easter Friendship Concert takes place on Saturday in Moscow – and the Irish Norwegian song will be given pride of place at it.Read More
Longtime U2 producer Steve Lillywhite's mix of The Joshua Tree track 'Red Hill Mining Town' was premiered by Irish DJ Dave Fanning and will get a limited-edition 12" vinyl release this month, along with selected stills from U2 photographer Anton Corbijn.Read More
Bob Marley's son Ziggy Marley will curate the reissue of Exodus 40 - The Movement Continues, which will be available as a gold-coloured vinyl or CD and will feature the original Release and the live Album. It will be released on June 2.Read More
The new music video featuring Nicki Minaj, Drake and Lil Wayne is visually interesting and accompanied with a great, smooth rap.Read More
We're gearing up for the launch of Music Cork, a new May three-dayer where you can come face to face with international industry heavyweights...Read More
Freeform, the American TV channel, releases the first trailer of Marvel’s Cloak and Dagger series.Read More
'Immigrant Boogie' will get a live airing here in October.Read More
Sofia Coppola’s The Beguiled has a new disturbingly enticing trailer.Read More
The Reids have announced a Vicar St. gig in October.Read More