The singer has lashed out at the critic who slated his Gaiety gig.
Chris de Burgh has launched an astonishing riposte to an Irish Times review of his Gaiety Theatre show. The review appeared in the Times last Thursday, and a copy of an email sent by the singer, in response, to the reviewer Peter Crawley, has been seen by Hot Press.
The review contained a generally negative reaction to the gig – one of three sell-out nights, which attracted an audience of over 3,000 to the theatre – and depicted de Burgh in a decidedly unflattering light.
The spat touches on an age-old debate concerning the role of the reviewer. Is there – as artists, managers and promoters often insist – a need, in the context of a review, to reflect what happened at a gig, and to report on what the audience reaction is? Or is a purely subjective response what it’s all about?
“A small man appears,” Crawley wrote, “in suit trousers and a white shirt, giving a little wave, like a businessman happy to have finished a long day of conference calls.
“This man is Chris de Burgh. You may have heard of him. The name alone summons a rush of associations, some of which carry a shudder, few of which fail to draw a smile.
“There is that warbly tenor,” the review continues, “the calling card of the mawkish balladeer (“I have never seen that dress you’re wearing . . . ”) which switches at the faintest invitation into a throaty belt: “DON’T PAY THE FERRYMAN!” There is that haircut, long at the back and wispy up front, entirely unruffled by 34 years in the music biz.
“And of course there is that cringe factor, unalleviated by the man’s apparent earnestness: his slightly tarnished squeaky clean persona, his claims to heal people with his hands, his indelible association with a time of shoulder pads and enormous hair. In short, it’s easy to snigger at de Burgh.”
Clearly stung by the personal nature of much of the comment in the review, de Burgh wrote to Crawley in terms that more than match – and indeed in places far exceed – the reviewer in terms of vituperation. The email includes a bilious sideswipe at Joe Breen, the former rock critic with the Irish Times, who now reviews country and roots music for the paper, and also served for a time as wine correspondent.
(Joe Breen's response, when Hot Press contacted him, was short and sweet: "I'm lucky to be blessed with a sense of humour.")
De Burgh's email to Crawley continues: “Your churlish review is an insult to all those who enjoyed their night out, and in these days of collapsing newspaper sales and an entire new generation on the way who will get their information online, you may be looking for another job sooner rather than later. Your pals in the pub must have loved your review, but it seems that you are universally loathed in the Theatre world; a leading Impresario has described you as ‘puffed up with his own self-importance’, and a much loved and successful actress refers to you as ‘that loathsome little turd’. Great accolades, to be sure.”
Accusing the reviewer of having gone to the show with his mind made up, he goes on: “… to totally ignore what actually happened and launch a personal attack is so transparent that any reader can see that it was pointless even writing it, as you were the only person who attended the show that night who didn't ACTUALLY WANT TO BE THERE!!”
“It was a great gig,” Noel McHale of MCD told Hot Press. “The reaction was amazing – he was getting standing ovations from half way through the show. The band were shit hot, the musicianship was amazing and the production was superb – they did things with the lighting and with special effects that I’d never seen before. Technically, it was brilliant. But none of that was reflected in the review – which doesn’t seem fair or balanced.”
Peter Crawley’ Reflections On The Letter
Peter Crawley told Hot Press that he thinks the problem here is that de Burgh’s public and private personas have become mixed up.
“I sort of felt I could write about Chris de Burgh, this persona, and for it not really to emotionally trouble him. Genuinely, I think – that’s maybe my naivete – that somebody with a career of over 30 years standing will take it in his stride,” said Crawley.
But the Irish Times critic adds that there’s another aspect of de Burgh which may be at the root of this disagreement: “I think there’s a disconnect between how he sees himself and his understanding of what a perception of him might be. You see that in his performance, where suddenly he portrays himself as a rock and roller without fully understanding what rock and roll might be. And bridling against the whole crooner tag, which is a better description of what his music is and what his music was and what it means at a particular time.”
“To be inflexible after so many years makes you a nostalgia act and you have to accept that as part of the package. I guess, not being able to see that, makes him, in my mind, a little bit distanced from the scene – not having a very good outside objective perspective of himself. Or maybe not able to disentangle the idea of Chris de Burgh, the person who is a good father or a nice guy or a good guy to have a drink with, and Chris de Burgh that figure: the guy on the stage, the guy on the album cover, the guy in the video, the singer of those verses. I guess a lot of us never have to handle the idea of a public persona and a private life and I guess maybe you take things personally that aren’t meant personally. And I guess maybe, on my side, I should be better aware that things can be taken personally that aren’t meant that way,” said Crawley.
So, is this just another case of the age old debate about how objective/subjective reviewers can/should be?
“There’s no such thing as complete objectivity. You can’t really have a structuralist reading of a concert! So everything is subjective but must be argued. You have to back up a position. While prejudice isn’t going to help you, you have to take to evidence of the performance and any evidence that’s kind of attached to a persona that’s built up,” said Crawley.
“Obviously, I was surprised that it evidently was so wounding and clearly stuck in his craw. And, you know, you do tend to lose sight of the fact that when you’re talking about a public persona, there’s somebody with a mum and there’s somebody who gets hurt and somebody who is going to take it poorly. But the alternative is criticism which is nothing but unmitigated praise and I don’t think that’s especially helpful either,” he said.
Asked about his reaction on receiving de Burgh’s email, the critic said (with maybe just a hint of irony at times): “If you read it, it’s funny. It’s a little bit – I mean, you do cringe. In fairness, he has written this to be amusing and you’ve got to hand it to him – he’s obviously spent a long time and a lot of effort finding out who I am. That’s almost touching really.”
Crawley mentioned that, though the letter “seems to have circulated rather widely,” he had understood it to be a personal correspondance.
“It was, at least, addressed to me and he did ask to meet. So I wrote back and offered a few times that I’m available to meet him. I haven’t heard back yet but I think the offer stands,” he said.
For the full text of Chris de Burgh’s letter, click here.
The list of 13 Irish acts set to perform at this year’s South By Southwest (SXSW) Music Conference in Austin, Texas has just been announced.Read More
David Bowie was posthumously honoured with the Best British Solo Artist and Best British Album for ‘Blackstar’ at last night’s BRIT Awards. While other big winners on the night included Adele who scooped the Global Success Award, Beyonce deservedly took home the gong for Best International Female and Drake was named the Best International Male artist.Read More
The 30-year-old actress said she was “racially profiled” recently at the Heathrow Airport in London, because she covered her hair with a headscarf.Read More
The American singer-songwriter will headline a show at Dublin’s Whelan’s this May.Read More
The 2017 Brit Award will take place tonight, February 22.Read More
Sziget Festival, the 7 day festival on an island north of Budapest, has announced the first 22 acts for its 2017 event.Read More
After topping the Irish Charts with his debut album Human Rag’n’Bone Man takes us behind the scenes in the latest instalment of the Beats by Dr. Dre's Beat x Beat series.Read More
Body & Soul music festival have revealed the first acts who will be heading to Ballinlough Castle, Westmeath, this summer.Read More
The National Opera House, Vicar Street, Mike The Pies and Boyle’s of Slane were also among the winners on the night...Read More
Katy Perry takes viewers to Oblivia in official video for 'Chained to the Rhythm'.Read More
J COLE has announced a 3Arena Dublin date as part of The 4 Your Eyez Only tour.Read More
The Los Angeles-based trio will release the single, originally from PJ Harvey's 1995 album To Bring You My Love, this Friday, February 24.Read More
Stormzy, who is nominated for British Breakthrough Act at the upcoming Brits which takes place next week, releases his new album 'Gang Sings & Prayer' on Friday, 24 February.Read More
The second season of Chelsea Handler's talk show Chelsea will return to the Netflix streaming service this Friday (14 April) at 8am Irish time.Read More
Cork musician Talos (aka Eoin French) has just dropped his new single, 'Odyssey'. It's taken from his debut album 'Wild Alee', which will be released in April.Read More
Game of Two Halves from Former Green on Red ManRead More
The co-founder of the progressive rock band said that "musicians have an absolute right, a duty, to open their mouths to speak out."Read More
The U2 frontman thanked the Vice President for defending PEPFAR - the US Government initative to prevent AIDS/HIV - on the White House floor.Read More
Tower Records (Dublin), Music Zone (Cork) and OMG@Zhivago (Galway) to open at midnight on Thursday, March 2 ahead of official release this Friday.Read More
Hollywood star Matt Damon has revealed that he has such a strong grá for Ireland that he dreams about one day splashing out on a lighthouse somewhere along the rugged Wild Atlantic Way.Read More
Grammy ® award-nominated rapper, singer, producer, and artist Jidenna has just unleashed his anxiously awaited full-length debut album, 'The Chief' on Wondaland Records/Epic Records.Read More
Sonya Kelly's award-winning play 'How to Keep an Alien' has already received the stamp of approval from audiences in Ireland, Australia, London, Edinburgh, New York and Paris…and now it’s heading to New Zealand. But Irish theatre fans will have one last chance to see the play before it goes on tour Down Under when it's staged in Drogheda on 9 March.Read More
Lana Del Ray has just released the first single 'Love' from her eagerly anticipated new album, which will be released later this year.Read More
IFTA will host renowned filmmaker Martin Scorsese for a Masterclass in Film, as well as the John Ford Award presentation, in Dublin next weekendRead More
Pickups, which is directed by Jamie Thraves, will be screened at the Irish Film Institute at 20.15pm, Saturday 18, with a Q&A after the show.Read More
The British singer-songwriter keeps defending his place on top of the charts.Read More
The glorious debut album from British soul star shoots straight for the top spot on its first week.Read More
The British comedian will be bringing his 'Humanity' stand-up show to the 3Arena this summer.Read More
Breathtakingly emotional coming-of-age film examines sexuality, race, and identity.Read More
Brian Wilson will perform live this summer in Dublin.Read More
Irish international footballer Anthony Stokes has been ordered to pay €230,000 in damages to an Elvis Presley impersonator he headbutted and seriously injured in a Dublin nightclub.Read More
The critically-acclaimed singer will be returning to Ireland for three dates in September, following the release of his sixteenth studio album, Prisoner, which is on sale today.Read More
The live version of 'How Would You Feel (Paean)' was released this morning.Read More
Castle of Song and Turning Pirate are getting ready to put on two intimate evenings of song and storytelling in Galway and Dublin, with Ronan O’Snodaigh, Roesy and Ye Vagabonds giving performances.Read More
Linkin Park fans will be excited to learn that the band have announced that their eagerly anticipated new album, entitled 'One More Light' will be released on 19 May.Read More
Community groups throughout Dublin City will be taking centre stage at national theatres, galleries, museums and performance venues across the capital over the coming weeks to perform and display artworks developed with artists through "Dublin’s Culture Connects: The National Neighbourhood programme."Read More
Michael Jackson's album 'Thriller' has just become the first album in RIAA Gold & Platinum Program history to be certified 33x Diamond for United States sales and streams.Read More
The trailer for Sandy Wexler – a new Adam Sandler comedy that will air exclusively on Netflix from 14 April – has just been uploaded on social media.Read More
The country singer will be making his way to Dublin this March.Read More
Thousands of you made your nominations. Now we can reveal the shortlist for "The Hotties" Live Venue of the Year 2017.Read More
Ahead of their Irish tour, which kicks off tonight in Voodoo Belfast, the avant-garde rockers are back with the first single from their upcoming EP mkll (part 2).Read More
Ahead of his shows on February 19 and 20, a final batch of tickets were released for Drake's shows at the 3Arena.Read More
Luke Fitzgerald, in his new role as Ambassador for the PRO12 Final, has kicked off the 100 day countdown tothe May 27 decider at the Aviva Stadium.Read More
Some of Ireland's finest live acts will help the weekly podcasters celebrate hitting the half century mark.Read More
He might be one of the biggest sports stars on the planet, but the UFC lightweight champion Conor McGregor has dismissed the notion that he's an A-list Celeb, bluntly saying: "I'm not a celebrity. I break people's faces for money and bounce!"Read More
Tinie Tempah, who has just announced that his eagerly anticipated new album will be released on 31 March, will perform his latest single this Friday night on BBC's The Graham Norton Show at 10.35pm.Read More
On top of her live show at the Button Factory with Canadian singer Austra this March, Pixx has announced the date for the release of her first album.Read More
It's awards season and we're down to our final vote off for the Hot Press Reader's Poll. Thousands of you made nominations and we've now announced the finalists so it's time to cast your votes! [the venue of the year voting will close on MONDAY 20th February as the winner will be announced at the IMRO Live Music Venue of the Year Awards] Everyone who votes (in any section) by then will have the chance to win tickets to the IMRO Live Music Venue of the Year Awards.Read More
Three-piece Limerick punk band Slow Riot are back with ' Pink December 'Read More
The poem, which was commissioned for the St. Patrick's Day Festival, is an honest, clear-sighted odyssey into Ireland as we know it today.Read More
Stiff Little Fingers will be playing at Belsonic this summer, along with The Stranglers, The Ruts DC, The Outcasts & punk legend Terri Hooley.Read More
A truly incredible line-up features Sigma, Primal Scream, The Coronas, Foy Vance and Badly Drawn Boy.Read More
Caffé Rockers, straight up burgers & tasty Belgian Blondes are all on this fortnight’s menu.Read More
'Something's Got a Hold of My Heart', the cover of Gene Pitney's '60s classic, is available to stream and download as of today.Read More
The “Catch & Release” singer will make an appearance in Dublin this spring.Read More
The Brooklynites will return to Dublin this May.Read More
'Coming of Age' is taken from Julia Jacklin's debut album Don't Let The Kids Win.Read More
Tickets for the Irish gigs go on sale this Friday.Read More
Wild Beast, Girl Band, Shit Robot, David Kitt and many more will play at the Tullamore weekender in August.Read More
August Wells, the musical project formed by Dublin native Kenneth Griffin (formerly of Rollerskate Skinny, Kid Silver and Favourite Sons) and New York pianist John Rauchenberger, have announced an Irish tour for February and March.Read More
Musician Moby has taken to social media to claim that the Russians do have enough damaging inside information that could potentially bring down Donald Trump’s controversial reign as the so-called leader of the free world.Read More
Bill Whelan's musical ‘The Train’ will travel to The Mac in Belfast’s Cathedral Quarter, following its run this Easter at the Abbey Theatre.Read More
Megadeth picked up the award for Best Metal Performance at the Grammys last night - but the house band accidentally played a Metallica song as they accepted the prize.Read More
Grammy award-winning country stars Jason Isbell and The 400 Unit have announced a show at The Olympia Theatre in October.Read More
You can help fund Thomas Walsh & Co.'s seventh album now.Read More
We've an in-depth preview in the new issue of Hot Press, out on Thursday.Read More
The Leeside rockers will play in Galway this Wednesday.Read More
Culture Vultures – the salon-theme pop culture event co-curated by Tony Clayton-Lea and Andrea Keogh – celebrates its 3rd birthday with an event on Monday March 6 at The Sound House.Read More
No bunnies were boiled, but otherwise it was full-on Fatal Attraction...Read More
Longtime U2 fans have launched a campaign to make a film dedicated to U2's most dedicated followers.Read More
The Irish music supergroup are coming to venue near you this April.Read More
The collaboration performance of Lady Gaga and Metallica was marred by the non-working microphone of Metallica front man James Hetfield.Read More
Dublin-born producer Kevin Killen has praised David Bowie at the Grammys, where the late star was honoured with five posthumous awards.Read More
At Sunday night’s Grammy Awards Adele dedicated her Album of the Year award to Beyoncé, who she beat out for the honour.Read More
The Illnois post-rock band are heading to Dublin early in September.Read More
The American hip-hop group were joined by Anderson .Paak and long-time collaborator Busta Rhymes for their politically charged performance.Read More
The Bostonians will be doing their Celtic punk thing in July...Read More
Ormeau Park & Malahide Castle receive respective visits in June.Read More
The musical La La Land scooped five major gongs at last night’s BAFTAs ceremony in London.Read More
Adele scooped five gongs and David Bowie was posthumously honoured with his swan song album also picking up five Grammys at the awards ceremony last night.Read More
Launched today in Dublin, Let's Celebrate 2017 includes a Paul McGuinness plea for more government support for the arts.Read More
Ed Sheeran is not going anywhere.Read More
See the all the listings for Music Network's Spring 2017 season, featuring jazz supergroup Dinosaur; cellist Emmanuelle Bertrand; and fiddler Darol Anger, who will tour with his band Republic of Strings.Read More
A controversial 10-part series has led people to call for a boycott of the prominent streaming service.Read More
Due to public demand, Kings Of Leon have added a second Dublin date at 3Arena.Read More
The Irish singer-songwriter Imelda May released her new ballad ‘Black Tears’ today, which previously premiered on BBC Radio 2 with her stunning live video.Read More
A US federal appeals court has rejected President Donald Trump's attempt to reinstate his ban on citizens from seven mainly Muslim countries.Read More
The producer also cracked a few jokes about Trump's gaffe-prone consigliere Kellyanne Conway.Read More
After ending a successful 2016 with a sold-out headline show to 15,000 people in his hometown of Dublin, Gavin James is ready to kick start 2017 with the launch of his new single out today, entitled 'I Don’t Know Why.'Read More
Cannabis should be made available to treat a limited range of medical conditions, according to a new report that will be published later today by the Department of Health.Read More