Sex Column: People do make false allegations of rape - but rarely

It is very hard to get a conviction in a rape case. This is one of the reasons why there is a widespread belief that many accusations of rape are false.

When somebody is accused of rape and found not guilty by the courts, it does not necessarily follow that the person who made the compliant lied.

There are all kinds of reasons why this might happen. The police may have got the wrong suspect. Eye-witness accounts vary and our memories – particularly if we have been traumatised – can be unreliable. In some cases, there is not enough evidence to convict – this is particularly true in date rape cases. Having listened to all the evidence, the jury might decide that there is reasonable doubt. Most of us believe it is better to let a possibly guilty person go free than send a potentially innocent person to jail.

Sometimes through no fault of their own, the victim is simply not believed, or makes a bad impression on the jury. Once again, traumatised people may not come across as coherent, leading the jury to doubt his or her word. In some cases, the jury may be prejudiced against the complainant – if you are working class, trans, a migrant, a minority or a sex worker you are less likely to be believed.

It is very hard to get a conviction in a rape case. This is one of the reasons why there is a widespread belief that many accusations of rape are false. It is commonly assumed that women cry rape for number of reasons – because they regret their sexual behaviour, want revenge or because they want attention. There is also a belief that innocent men are at the mercy of mendacious women who will ruin their reputations and have them sent to jail on a whim.

That’s not the case. A US study found that over a ten-year period only between 2 and 10 percent of accusations could be classified as “false.” The reason for the 8 percent gap is down to poor police procedures. If the victim decides not to co-operate with the police, makes inconsistent statements, was drunk at the time of the assault, or waits weeks, months or years before making a compliant, the police sometimes log these as false accusations. That doesn’t mean no rape happened or the accuser was lying.

Now before anyone starts screaming that the accused are “innocent until proven guilty” let’s admit that there are indeed cases where an accusation is false. It’s rare, but it does happen.

Studies have been done on false accusers and some interesting patterns have emerged. It seems that certain types of people are more likely than others to make a false claim of rape. The writer Sandra Newman did an analysis of these – and it is these people I want to talk about here.

The first and most prevalent group of false accusers are teenage girls. Teenage girls who get pregnant, get home late or get in trouble of some sort may try and deflect blame or punishment by claiming to have been raped.

These girls almost never report the false rape to the police. However their parents do. Two US studies found that around half of all false rape accusations made to police happen because someone else – not the fake victim – lodged a complaint, generally a parent. These cases rarely make it to court. Once the lie has served its purpose, the fake victim is unlikely to co-operate, or name a perpetrator.

There are however a handful of cases where adults pursue false rape claims through the criminal justice system. Interestingly enough, although false accusers are popularly assumed to be women, both men and women have been guilty of this.

There seems to be four motives for doing so – mental illness, personal gain, revenge or to establish an alibi.

One factor that is common amongst adult false accusers is a history of childhood sexual abuse. Because of this, false accusers with mental illness may truly believe they have been raped. Others have a personality disorder that is similar to Munchausen’s Syndrome and they generally have a history of making other types of false claims.

Adult false accusers motivated by personal gain are not always after money. In the United States, a large number of these false claims are made by people without medical insurance who need hospital care that they can’t afford. They don’t generally name a perpetrator as they are not interested in having anyone punished. However, those who are after money generally have a long history of making sketchy injury claims too.

Now let’s look at revenge. The cliché has it that “hell hath no fury like a woman scorned” – but it’s not true when it comes to false rape claims. Since 1989, 52 men convicted of rape have been exonerated according to the US National Registry of Exonerations – in the same period, 790 people were exonerated for murder. Of these 52 cases, none were convicted because of a scorned woman. A number of them featured accusers who traded sex for some gain, only for the person to renege on the agreement.

The last group comprises those who need an alibi. Like the largest group – teenage girls who use rape as an excuse – people in this group are trying to cover up something, for the most part infidelity. Like the lying teenage girls, these people don’t generally report a false attack to police either – someone else does so on their behalf, a partner or concerned friend.

The Los Angeles Police Department found that 78 percent of false rape claims were of aggravated assault. Fake victims rarely tell stories that involve date rape or could be the result of a misunderstanding between two drunk people. Instead they are more likely to claim that the perpetrator had a weapon, or that they were beaten or injured as well as raped.

We remember the big false accusation cases, such as the story of “Jackie” – the woman at the centre of the Rolling Stone “A Rape on Campus” controversy. Jackie falsely claimed she was gang-raped at a frat party at the University of Virginia. Before making this claim, she told a fellow student she was dying to elicit his sympathy.

Last year in the UK, Jemma Beale was jailed for ten years for making a series of false rape claims – four different incidents in three years, all accusing strangers.

Like Jackie, Jemma has a history of making false claims and also seems to have been trying to elicit sympathy from a former partner. In both cases, the women told stories of aggravated rapes – not date rapes, where consent might have been seen as ambiguous.

False accusers do great damage. Firstly, they do great harm to those they accuse. Beale had someone prosecuted and convicted – although it has since been overturned. They also make us assume that false accusations are more common than they really are. And they make it harder for real victims to come forward for fear that they will not be believed.

As awful as these women’s actions were, it is important to remember that they are outliers.

When someone you know or admire is accused of rape, you want to believe they are innocent. That’s human nature – we prefer to think the best of those we know.

When someone you know or admire claims to have been raped, you want to believe them too – and you probably should. The accused may be innocent until proven guilty, but if a woman or man claims to have been raped, statistically speaking at least, they are almost certainly telling the truth.

 

Related Articles

Six Nations Preview: Irish international legend Keith Wood previews our chances

Rugby may be a funny old game and unpredictable with it. But as the Six Nations 2018 tournament rolls around, there is real cause for optimism in the Irish camp. We might, says Irish international legend Keith Wood, even justify our status as favourites…

Read More

Why the Eight Amendment affects all women

If there is one thing that Philomena Canning of Midwives for Choice would like you to know, it's this: the 8th Amendment is not just about abortion.

Read More

Sex Column: Lesbianism is on the march

As women age we have many great things to look forward to - stretchy pants, cat collecting, and now, it appears, late on-set lesbianism.

Read More

Did Hugh Hefner's Porn Empire Change the World?

Needless to say there are very divergent views on the effect of the so-called Playboy revolution. But the truth is that, far from being liberated, women's right to express themselves sexually is still oppressed, far and wide, around the world - sometimes brutally. It is our responsibility to change that.

Read More

Huge Turnout As Lisa Hannigan Sings At March For Choice

The annual March for Choice took place in Dublin today, and tens of thousands turned out for what will – almost certainly – be the last of these occasions before the referendum to Repeal the 8th. Anne Sexton reports...

Read More

EXCLUSIVE:Rob Kearney reflects on life, his career, Irish rugby, and politics

It might seem impossibly glamorous to fans, but being a professional rugby player is a tough, demanding and sometimes lonely life. Rob Kearney talks about his attitude to life – and to work.

Read More

College is all about sex

Okay, that's not entirely true. But when you reach third level, for the majority of people, a whole new world of sexual possibility opens up. If you want to make the most of it without screwing up, just follow our three rule programme...

Read More

Sex Column: Crossing cultural boundaries with sex

How often have you strayed from your own close cultural type, in a sexual encounter or in forming a relationship? Or might you be even more turned on by the thought of crossing cultural boundaries in pursuit of the best possible sex? And to what extent are our sexual desires a matter of conditioning that we can – and possibly should – change?

Read More

Sex Column: Is monogamy the only option for couples?

A fascinating new book suggests it’s at least worth questioning standard sexual mores...

Read More

Lisa Harding talks about her depictions of sex-trafficking in her new novel Harvesting

Lisa Harding’s new novel, Harvesting, is a powerful tale about the current sex-trafficking crisis in Europe.

Read More

Sex Column: I’m Coming, I’m Coming!

No, we are not talking about that moment when you are late for a dinner appointment and your partner is shouting at you to get a move on. Rather, it is that special occasion when the impact of an orgasm kicks in, so that the inevitable must happen – and does. So how do you think you’d look, if there was a close-up on your face, in a porn movie?

Read More

Live Report: RIOT at Vicar St

RIOT, at Vicar St. is a hugely engaging smorgasbord of artistic delights, with Emmet Kirwan and Panti Bliss to the fore.

Read More

Let's Talk About Sex - Ireland's long, unfinished journey from sexual conservatism to liberalism

40 years ago, like a European Afghanistan, Ireland was hopelessly conservative in relation to sex and sexuality. However, the local equivalent of the Taliban have gradually been ousted – and this country has become a far more open, liberal, inclusive and tolerant place. That there is no room for complacency goes without saying…

Read More

Sex Column: Playing the Whore

It's one of the commonest insults in the English language- and it's usually directed at women. The truth, of course, is that there is nothing wrong with earning money for providing sexual services...

Read More

What Sort Of Monster Would Pretend To Use A Condom and Let It Slip Off?

…Or puncture it? They are out there, you know: men and women who are hell bent on hoodwinking others into unprotected sex. Their aims may be different – but it is rape either way…

Read More

Sex Column: What Happens When A Man Comes?

Or should that be cums? Well, either way, it is a fascinating question – all the more so given that without it, well you, for one, wouldn’t be here. So get ready to take notes, girls and boys…

Read More

Book Review: Skintown by Ciaran McMenamin

Ciarán McMenamin’s debut novel Skintown is a hypnotic, alcohol soaked, adrenaline-fuelled rush of a book

Read More

Sleeping With The Enemy

Would you put up with a racist or a xenophobe if he – or she – happened to be good in the sack? And how important is it to love that we share the same ideological inclinations?

Read More

In Sex Does One Size Fit All?

For example, there’s a theory that the way to a woman’s heart is through straightforward kissing, cunnilingus and fingering. Well, what do you think, eh?

Read More

Book Review: Colm Tóibín, House of Names

Read More

Bright Lights, Big Orgasm - This Fortnight's Sex Column

For a long time, our correspondent has been seeing things when she has an orgasm. When she investigated what was going on, she was in for a surprise…

Read More

Is Hate The Best Way To Love (And Have Sex?)

It may seem perverse, but people often bond over how much they dislike something – or someone. In fact, if you play your cards well enough, hating the same things may be the best way of ending up in bed with someone you fancy.

Read More

How Many People Have You F*cked?

In a nice way, that is! A UK research project found that both men and women are suspicious of sexually successful (some might say promiscuous) people. So, with it being Valentine’s Day, we have to ask: how come they keep getting laid?

Read More

US Muslims living in Trump's America - An Interview with Twitter Queen Hend Amry

She is a US citizen. But, if Donald Trump has his way, her name will go into a new kind of black book: the so-called Muslim Register. Hend Amry has been commenting on the shift to right-wing populism in the US and elsewhere via Twitter, under the @libyaliberty handle, earning an impressively large following in the process…

Read More

Apollo House Occupiers: We Need to Be at The Forefront of the Fight Against Homelessness

A musician by trade, Quentin Sheridan was homeless – and so he put out a call on Facebook. The occupation of Apollo House by Home Sweet Home is the result. But it is only the start of a battle, in which Ireland can provide the lead

Read More

“Simon Coveney, come down and talk with us,” says Glen Hansard

The singer has issued an invitation to the Minister for Housing to visit Apollo House, in Dublin, which has been occupied by campaigners who aim to bring an end to homelessness.

Read More

Sex column: Men should be able to control their fertility

With the exception of condoms, the responsibility for avoiding pregnancy has generally fallen on women. But men are entitled to control their own fertility too. The question is: how?

Read More

Life During Wartime: An Interview with Helena Mulkerns

Helena Mulkerns’ new short story collection draws on her extraordinary experiences as an aid worker, which brought her to the heart of conflict zones in Eritrea and Afghanistan.

Read More

Book Review: Conor Brady, A Hunt in Winter

Read More

Sex News: My Night with a Female Hetero Romantic Bisexual

It might sound complicated – but I was very impressed indeed with Laura when she gave such a wonderfully precise definition of her sexual identity. Which got me thinking: what about all of those other interesting shades of sexual orientation? Well, it turns out that there is a word for most all of them!

Read More

Cannabis Makes Sex Better

Cannabis lube, that is. And, based on our sex columnist's personal experiments, it heightens sexual pleasure only for women. Sadly, you won’t get it over the counter in Ireland – though that might change in the future. We hope…

Read More

When An Interest In Sex Was Considered A Form of Madness

In terms of our understanding of the human mind, it is important to remember that we are only ever getting there. Not so long ago, after all, a woman who enjoyed sex was likely to be branded as a nymphomaniac.

Read More

In Goth We Trust

Irish author Conor O’Callaghan’s debut novel, the gothic mystery story Nothing On Earth, is one of the most gripping books of the year.

Read More

Book Review: Margaret Atwood, Hag-Seed:The Tempest Retold

Read More

Repeal The 8th & The Struggle Of Irish Women

Since the introduction of the 8th Amendment to the Constitution in 1983, women in Ireland have had to live with a shockingly restrictive regime on abortion, which has resulted in numerous deaths and untold trauma. Now, the Irish public is saying: no more…

Read More

Book Review: Mary Gaitskill The Mare

Read More

Men Are Sex Objects Too - Anne Sexton talks double standards and the female gaze

The myth that only men treat the opposite sex as objects, is just that - a myth. The sooner women are more honest about their lustful feelings, and the sooner society stops treating sexually open women as sluts the better it will be for all of us.

Read More

Book Review: Laura Kasischke Minds Of Winter

Laura Kasischke, the critically acclaimed and nationally bestselling poet and author returns with a tense psychological thriller

Read More

An Interview With Miranda Sawyer: Neither Out of Touch Nor Out Of Time

Journalist Miranda Sawyer’s compelling and humorous new book, Out Of Time, explores the challenges of turning forty and maintaining a rock and roll edge.

Read More

Book Review: Liz Nugent, Lying In Wait

Liz Nugent’s Lying in Wait comes with praise from Sebastian Barry and Marian Keyes, among others.

Read More

Meet UnderCurrent, a Cabaret Like No Other

UnderCurrent are a group unlike any other in Ireland. A mix of cabaret, musical theatre, burlesque, physical comedy, banter and dance, they are also the only performance troupe in the country composed entirely of LGBTQ members.

Read More

Hats Off To The Stone Roses

The progenitors of Britpop came to Marlay Park in Dublin yesterday – and the crowd lapped it up. Report: Anne Sexton

Read More

Book Review: Conor O'Callaghan, Nothing on Earth

Anne Sexton gives her take on Conor O'Callaghan's debut novel.

Read More

The Shoos talk to Anne Sexton about their comeback

This four-piece cut their teeth busking in Temple Bar, but their journey is just beginning.

Read More

Front Lines: Senior Citizens Make Abortion Pill Stand In NI

With women being given jail sentences for using the abortion pill in Northern Ireland, three activists decided that it was time to act – and made a startling confession to the PSNI.

Read More

Anne Sexton explores modern dating rituals and our First Dates obsession

First Dates offered a glimpse into the way people behave when they are looking for a romantic liaison - and maybe some sex into the bargain. But how different was the TV version from people's pursuit of a good time - and what does the history of dating tell us about how we view this ritual?

Read More

Book Review:Shrill Notes From A Loud Woman

Read More

Sex: Are You The Sexiest Version Of Yourself?

Read More

Book Review: Shylock is my name

Read More

A new beginning

Teenager David Beattie has written a powerful and insightful account of growing up trans in Ireland.

Read More

Tinder: Is there an orgy of hot sex waiting for you?

The ‘dating’ app makes great claims in relation to the numbers using it. But are people hooking up and having sex successfully through it? Now, that is a very good question…

Read More

Book Review: In the Wake of The Rising

Read More

Sexed Up: The Fuckzone is where bullies thrive.

Make no mistake, casual sex can be brilliant, wonderful, even life-affirming. But in the fuckzone, things are different. Because this is where a woman is just a piece of pussy or a man is no better than a dick or an asshole on legs...

Read More

Book Review: A Slanting Of The Sun Donal Ryan

Since the release of his acclaimed first novel, The Spinning Heart, Ryan has established himself as one of Ireland’s most talented writers.

Read More

Sex Column: Sex Equalled Shame

Eighties Ireland: in a country where divorce was impossible, unmarried mothers were treated like pariahs, gay sex was illegal and condoms could only be bought on prescription, finding the joy in sex was not easy. But the excitement of it was no less real.

Read More

Glenn Patterson Interview

Glenn Patterson’s latest novel tells the extraordinary story of John DeLorean’s time in Belfast – a saga of federal agents, undercover sting operations and alleged cocaine trafficking.

Read More

Sex Column: Ask every candidate will they repeal the 8th

The introduction of the 8th Amendment to the Constitution in 1983 was one of the most regressive pieces of manipulative political chicanery in the history of the Irish state. Repealing it is essential to establishing a regime in Ireland, which respects the reproductive rights of women. Let’s end the evasiveness by making it an election issue…

Read More

Book Review: Love Rewired By David Kavanagh

Read More

Book Review: The Noise of Time by Julian Barnes

Read More

Paddy Hayes - Queen Of Spies

Read More

On The Abortion Pill Bus

It may be highly illegal, but Irish women - including TD Ruth Coppinger - are willing to risk jail by taking the abortion pill all over Ireland. Anne Sexton and Julia Schimkus travelled to Galway with the pro-choice activists...

Read More

Queen Of Ireland

Life is a drag for Miss Panti - but wonderfully so!

Read More

Hanya Yanagihara Interview

Anne Sexton chats to Hanya Yanagihara, whose second novel A Little Life has been the subject of truly rapturous reviews...

Read More

Undermajordomo Minor - Patrick DeWitt

Read More

Beneath The Earth - John Boyne

Read More

Who Said Foreplay Was Just For Girls?

Men have been lectured for a long time about how ladies need a bit of foreplay before getting it on. But that is an axiom that rubs both ways – because men tend to like a long, slow build-up too...

Read More

Sex Column: Who Said Foreplay Was Just For Girls?

Men have been lectured for a long time about how ladies need a bit of foreplay before getting it on. But that is an axiom that rubs both ways – because men tend to like a long, slow build-up too...

Read More

Sex Column: Why Didn't She Leave Him?

...Or, in a different situation, you might ask, why didn’t he leave her? Abusive relationships are unfortunately common – and both sexes are victims. But perhaps you have to have lived through one to really understand the cruel dynamics at work...

Read More

Glenn Patterson - Interview

Acclaimed author Glenn Patterson continues his exploration of the Northern Irish psyche in his latest book, which cherry-picks his finest non-fiction pieces from the last decade.

Read More

Sex Column: Pick-Up Artists Are Wankers

The crass outlook of pick-up artists is insulting and fails to recognise each individual's unique attractiveness

Read More

Sex Column: If You've Got Something Unusual Hiding In Your Pants, Let Me Know...

There are no rules as to how much you reveal to prospective sexual partners. But it is probably true that – most of the time anyway – honesty is the best policy...

Read More

David Norris Interview

Before the gay marriage ‘Yes’ vote had people dancing in the streets, before civil partnerships, before gay people could publicly identify as such, Senator David Norris was waging a brave and often thankless fight on behalf of minorities in Ireland. In his first major interview since the referendum he recounts his long struggle with prejudice in Ireland...

Read More

Interview with Tender Author Belinda McKeon

With her second novel Tender dealing with homosexuality, emotional abuse and mental illness, Belinda McKeon reflects on the repressive, oppressive culture of mid '90s Ireland and the perverse pleasure she takes in pushing readers' buttons.

Read More

Sex Column: Sex On The Beach

It may be the name of a cocktail, but it is also a reasonably popular pastime. So is public sex a good idea? And how are you best to go about it?

Read More

Grey - EL James

Read More

Sex Column: Why Sex Is Evil...

Every now and then, they come out of the woodwork: people who believe that thinking, talking and writing about sex in a positive way is a sin and should be punished. It is a bit scary when someone like this tracks down your email address just to tell you...

Read More

Joy Unconfined - Marriage Equalitiy

As the results came in, crowds gathered in Dublin Castle to hear them. It became on of he biggest and best parties Ireland has ever seen...

Read More

Anne Enright - The Green Road

The novel is about an Irish family and all their problems in life from 1980 on and written in episodic style.

Read More

Sex Column: The Right To Love In Broad Daylight

It is vital to gay couples that the upcoming referendum on same sex marriage should be passed. But an even bigger prize is the feeling that we are living in an open, inclusive society that a resounding victory would inspire. So, make sure to get out and vote ‘Yes’...

Read More

Sex Column: Why I'd Like To Be A Man

When it comes to sex, men have it far easier and far better than women. In fact, there are ten good reasons why a sex change might just be the best option...

Read More

Sex Column: We Need More Sex, Not Less

A lot of concern has been expressed in conventional media about ‘hook-up’ culture. Curiously, however, the impact of social media and online mate-seeking sites seems to be that people are having less sex rather than more. Something will have to be done about it, is all we can say...

Read More

Sex Column: You Lick Mine And I'll Suck Yours!

It is an invitation that most people would find extremely difficult to turn down. But there are those who prefer giving head one at a time to the classic 69. Which side of the great oral sex debate are you on?

Read More

Sex Column: 9 Things I Learned About Sex

When Hot Press ran a competition for a columnist to write about sex, the competition was pretty hot. In the end, we chose a certain feisty, red-headed female, who wrote with wit, verve and style – and whose name just happened to have the word ‘sex’ in it. Clearly it was a role that she had been destined to, um, perform...

Read More

Sex Column: Women Enjoy Porn

And there’s nothing wrong with that! Indeed, while sexual conservatives try to claim otherwise, the reality is that men and women are really very similar in their appetites for sex, porn and all the rest...

Read More

Sex Column: Give And You Shall Receive Sex...

That was the implied message in Teleflora’s 2012 Valentine’s Day ad, which featured the model Adriana Lima. Is that really what romance is all about?

Read More

Sex Column: 2015 Will Be The Year Of BDSM

That’s bondage, discipline, sadism and masochism to you and me. Oh, and there will also be copious face- sitting; lots of gay sex – some of it within marriage hopefully; and vibrators that know what you like. Bring it on!

Read More

Inside Ireland's BDSM Scene

During the Graham Dwyer murder trial, members of the Irish BDSM scene were sometimes depicted in unflattering terms. So what is BDSM all about?

Read More

Hot Press examines the Housing Crisis

Cowboy landlords, substandard living conditions and ever increasing costs are just some of the problems facing people in rented accommodation, and many of those in difficulty are afraid to speak up.

Read More

Sex Column: Sex Is In The Air

But not always in a good way! Because someone out there apparently thinks that sex toys specially designed and packaged for Christmas are, like, a good idea! Starting with the Barack Obama dildo…

Read More

Sex Column: I Rather Like My Friend's Husband, So...

It’s a tough one. The man you want just happens to be hooked up — with your best friend. If you really want him, there’s only one way to go about it. But should you dare?...

Read More

Seek And Ye Shall Find - Get Working Special

As Ireland emerges from a period of economic turbulence, there are now a myriad of ways to get a foothold in the jobs market.

Read More

WHY IS NOBODY INTERESTED IN SHAGGING ME?

That’s a question that more or less everyone has had to ask themselves at some time in their lives. Because, modern mating methods notwithstanding, getting regular sex is still a minefield for a lot of people to negotiate…

Read More

Sex Column: Warnings About Rape Are All Very Well, But…

It doesn’t make sense to start blaming social media for what is a horrible crime. Because the truth is that women are entitled to go about their lives free of the fear of rape…

Read More

Mental Health Special - Mind, Body, Spirit

It may be a cliché but there is a lot of truth to the notion of “a healthy body, healthy mind.” As Bressie notes in his emotional fitness tips, the food you eat affects your mood, and physical activity promotes the creation of serotonin, a neurotransmitter that makes you feel good.

Read More

Front Lines: Volunteer Force

Time spent overseas volunteering shouldn’t be treated as a holiday and is only worthwhile if you are prepared to put in some hard graft...

Read More
 

Advertise With Us


For information including benefits, key facts, figures and rates for advertising with Hot Press, click below

Advertise

Find us elsewhere