not a member? click here to sign up

U2 Manager Hails Irish Court Decision On Filesharing

The High Court in Dublin has given the green light to IRMA and Eircom's graduated response scheme.

The Hot Press Newsdesk, 16 Apr 2010



The High Court has cleared the way for the Irish Recorded Music Association and Eircom to implement their graduated response to illegal filesharing, which was agreed in February 2009 but held up by a legal objection.

Agreeing with IRMA’s assertion that “an IP address refers solely to the network address of a computer and is not personal data when in IRMA’s possession”, Mr. Justice Charleton said in his ruling: “The right to be identified with and to reasonably exploit one’s own original creative endeavour I regard as a human right. It is completely within the legitimate standing of Eircom to act, and to be seen to act, as a body, which upholds the law and Constitution. That is what the Court expects of both individuals and companies.

“The internet is only a means of communication,” Justice Charleton continued. “It has not rewritten the legal rules of each nation through which it passes. It is not an amorphous extraterrestrial body with an entitlement to norms that run counter to the fundamental principles of human rights. There is nothing in the criminal or civil law which legalises that which is otherwise illegal simply because the transaction takes place over the internet.”

One of the first people to react to the ruling is U2 manager Paul McGuinness who comments: “This is a landmark decision. The judge’s emphatic and eloquent words will be reported around the world, and be welcomed by musicians, composers, filmmakers and actors everywhere.”

Echoing those sentiments, IRMA Chairman Willie Kavanagh adds: “The whole music industry, including performers, composers and record labels, has been decimated by illegal peer to peer traffic and our losses amount to over €60m per annum. Our industry has lost 40% in sales value between 2005 and 2009 with devastating effects on Artists and creativity. Today’s decision is the first step back towards allowing Artists to make a living again.”

IRMA and Eircom’s graduated response scheme will now proceed to what they term “the educational and awareness campaign” stage. The ultimate sanction of Eircom disconnecting illegal filesharers will only be taken after the issuing of three official warnings, and due process.


Artist Related Content

Latest Related Articles For This Artist

Paul McGuinness receives Industry Icon Award

While his former charges were getting dickie-bowed up, former U2 manager – but still part of the team – Paul McGuinness was recognised by his peers with a Billboard Industry Icon Award.


News: 18 Jan 2014

Paul McGuinness to hand over U2 management reins

In a story that is creating headlines throughout the music, entertainment and media industries, Paul McGuinness has confirmed that he is stepping down as U2 manager, following a relationship with the band that has spanned five decades.


News: 13 Nov 2013

Paul McGuinness adds his voice to the growing concern among the music community regarding illegal file sharing

As IRMA (Irish Recorded Music Association) meet today to consider their position, U2's manager calls for a change in Irish legislation


News: 13 Oct 2010

30 remarkable years: Why McGuinness has been good for U2

He’s been at the helm with U2 since 1979. In the intervening time he’s been involved in every aspect of the career of the biggest rock band in the world. In a rare in-depth interview, Paul McGuinness talks about the highs and lows of managing the fab four and reflects on the State of the Nation and the implosion of the Irish economy.


Interview: 23 Mar 2009

Paul McGuinness calls for illegal downloaders to be punished

U2 manager Paul McGuinness has called for those who download music illegally to have their web access cut by their internet service provider.


News: 29 Jan 2008

best of ireland

Contact Us

Hot Press,
13 Trinity Street,
Dublin 2.
Rep. Of Ireland
Tel: +353 (1) 241 1500

Email:info@hotpress.ie

Click here for more contact information.

Click here to find out more about Hot Press

Hot Press always welcomes feed back so if you've got something to tell us click here.

Advertise With Us

For more detail on how to advertise with Hot Press click here or call us on +353 (1) 241 1540