Dan Stevens wasn’t joking when he described his latest series, Legion, as the “fake news” of superhero dramas. Nominally set in the X-Men universe, the much buzzed-about new show, which has just arrived on Fox, from the outset tries to drill into the viewer’s brain and muck about with their perception of reality. In the best sense, it’s like sitting through a Sean Spicer press conference scripted by Stan Lee.
In the title role, Downton’s dashing Dan is unrecognisably rough and ready. “Legion” is the superhero tag of David Haller, a troubled soul apparently suffering a multitude of mental traumas (unstated is the nugget that he is son of X-Men honcho Charles Xavier).
He has superpowers – or at least believes he has – but these are presented more as disadvantage than blessing. In the original comic book, Haller’s abilities were tied to the multiple personalities competing for dominance inside his head. To access a power he had to “become” the person controlling it.
This is rather more complicated than Superman locating a convenient phone booth in which to slip his underpants over his trousers. In the television series, Haller’s talents are portrayed as a straight-up curse which has pushed him to the brink of sanity. It’s a fantastic showcase for Stevens, who leaves us guessing whether what we are seeing is real or part of a waking fever dream.
To return to the Superman analogy, can you imagine a retelling of the Man of Steel that hedged its bets whether Clark Kent really was a flying crime-fighter or sick man battling dangerous delusions? How post-modern and thrilling would that be? (Answer: very).
“He’s exhibiting symptoms that had him diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia since his late teens,” Stevens told reporters earlier this month. “From a narrative point of view, that lends itself to a very playful tone, in that all of these realities are quite real.”
Legion has been created by Noah Hawley, who has achieved acclaim for his ingenious small-screen reworking of the Coen brothers’ Fargo. As with that project, here he takes a familiar property – the X-Men story has been told in a multitude of forms on the big screen across the past decade-and-a-half – and gives it an irresistible twist. Is Haller truly a superhero? Or are the voices in his mind merely hallucinogenic reverberations?
“I was interested, after Fargo, which is very objective storytelling, in doing something subjective, in the sense of, here’s a character who either has schizophrenia or he has these abilities,” Hawley told New York magazine. “He’s a haunted house, and the things that he’s seeing, the things that he’s hearing, they might have a logical explanation, but he doesn’t know that.”
Adding to the ambivalence is a unique visual sensibility somewhere between Stanley Kubrick and Iron Man. As the presence of iPads and other technology makes clear, Legion is set in the 21st century. So why is everyone dressed in ’70s-style sweaters and track-tops – and how to explain retro fixtures that might have been shipped straight from Mad Men?
“Noah was quite deliberate in not letting me know exactly, at any given moment, whether what was happening was real, so it was sort of up to me to decide,” Stevens said. “David is ready to accept almost anything as real, at any given moment, and that’s a really alive place to be as a performer. No matter how crazy and out there, David is ready to take on whatever happens.”
“Noah wanted to make sure that the audience was as confused as David is about what is real by not having a time or a place, never saying where we are,” production designer Michael Wylie told New York.
Far from an aberration, Legion can be seen as part of the next stage of comic book adaptations – an evolution occurring almost exclusively on television.
Yes, a whiff of self-awareness attended last year’s loveably scatalogical Deadpool movie. However, the small screen has otherwise emerged as the driving force behind what, in comic book terms, is tantamount to an uprising.
Consider Netflix’s trilogy of superhero sagas – Daredevil, Jessica Jones and Luke Cage (a fourth show, Iron Fist, arrives this spring). Here the fundamental conventions of comic book storytelling are turned on their heads, with nuanced storylines and characters who neither speak nor act like spandex clad do-gooders.
Yet far from a repudiation of the genre, there’s an argument that Legion and similar shows point to a thrilling new future. With bombastic comic book movies pitching tent at the box office for much of the year, there’s an imminent danger of ‘peak superhero’. You have already experienced the fatigue settling in, I am sure.
Thus if superheroes are to avoid the inexorable decline suffered by the western and the gangster flick they will have to outgrow their current juvenile tendencies and simplistic moralising. Legion, Luke Cage and their ilk represent the first steps in that transition.
“Will we ever get tired of superheroes? It’s almost like saying are we content with enough gun violence on screen or will ever get sick of sex scenes?,” Luke Cage star Mike Colter told me when we spoke last year. “You change the positions and it becomes appealing. If we don’t find those things entertaining, what’s left? Maybe we’ll go back to books.”
“I did want to be very careful about sending a message that all conflict can only be resolved through battle. There is a sense in a lot of these stories that everything always builds to a big fight,” Hawley said. “And certainly, if you’re doing a story about outsiders and empathy, I didn’t want to be drawn into the gravitational pull of that white hat vs black hat. I wanted to find a story that was just as exciting and interesting, but doesn’t send the message that in the end ‘might makes right’.”
Legion airs on Fox on Thursdays.
The Terrible Tangerine has ascended to the White House - but how will his dystopian presidency impact on the small screen?Read More
Brit soul star serves up the goods on glossy debutRead More
He's the up-and-coming songwriter of the moment - but don't write Declan McKenna off as just another Ed Sheeran clone.Read More
As part of the Hot Press ‘Hot for 2017’ special, here’s our run-down of the best international drama to watch out for in the months to come.Read More
Goth-pop crew turn their frowns upside downRead More
London-based Limerick trio whenyoung on breaking into the UK indie scene, why it pays to have a day job and the shadow cast by Brexit. By Ed PowerRead More
Eye-rolling return to form by madcap crew.Read More
Serial killer drama The Fall went out with a terrifying flourish, with career best performances by Gillian Anderson and Jamie Dornan. We talk to one of the show’s stars, Bronagh Taggart, and ask why this chilly thriller became such a word of mouth hit.Read More
It’s been a stand-out 12 months for Pixies, with a fantastic comeback album to their name and now the ultimate accolade of Hot Press Indie Heroes of the Year. Ed Power breaks the good news to the Boston legends.Read More
Adele is an all too rare example of a celebrity visibly retaining their humanity under the spotlight. Ed Power recalls the moment last year when Adele embraced her superstar status yet somehow found a way to stay normal.Read More
In a revelatory interview, Panti Bliss opens up about inclusion, exclusion and matters personal and private.Read More
It’s been a strange 12 months for Hot Press Man of the Year, Kanye West. Ed Power looks back at 365 days of heartache, scandal and sublime art from a troubled superstar.Read More
Impassioned Return from Sometime Libertines TroubadourRead More
On the 20th anniversary of Super Furry Animals’ debut album, frontman Gruff Rhys talks about taking the record back out on the road and offers his thoughts on the EU, Wales at the Euros and that time he drove a tank around Glastonbury.Read More
Swedish star flies feminist banner. Gender rules apply...Read More
Sublime R&B agit–prop from the cooler Knowles sister.Read More
Potent stadium rock from former wild child guitar-slingers.Read More
Synth-pop sadsters Poliça talk about Donald Trump, finding happiness when they least expected and their debt to Prince.Read More
Cult folkie embraces obscurity.Read More
As Black Francis and co return with their finest record in 25 years, the alt-rock luminaries talk egos, in-fighting and the controversial exit of bassist Kim Deal.Read More
Elusive singer suffers enervating case of trying too hardRead More
Where do you start with Jamie Treays? Here is an intense young man whose early career was dogged by severe panic attacks yet who has always aspired to an old fashioned, chart-slaying idea of stardom.Read More
With season two of Narcos freshly arrived in Netflix, Ed Power looks at how the series met the challenges of chronicling the larger-than-life story of cocaine kingpin Pablo Escobar.Read More
Artist on the rise Julia Jacklin tells Ed Power about coming of age in the mountains above Sydney, and why she can't wait to get back to Ireland for Electric Picnic.Read More
Triumphant return from likely lad emoterRead More
Dance duo deliver aural wallpaper on second outing.Read More
Indie rockers of the moment Wolf Alice look forward to Electric Picnic, contemplate their overnight rise and tell Ed Power about the thrills and challenges of meeting your heroes.Read More
After more than a decade on the go, Editors remain in rude health. Tom Smith tells Ed Power how the Picnic-bound rockers came through past upheavals to end up stronger than everRead More
Hollywood’s over-the-top master of ceremonies is making his first foray into television with a Netflix show chronicling the birth of hip hop. But, wonders Ed Power, can Baz Luhrmann’s The Get Down – the most expensive TV show in history – live up to the hype?Read More
Synth weirdos shrug off loss of talismanic vocalist and return with spellbinding fourth albumRead More
Lera Lynn's Southern-gothic country dirges were the only good thing to come out of True Detective season two. The singer tells Ed Power about her new album, out-acting Colin Farrell's moustache, and the darkness that informs her music.Read More
Mixed messages a-go-go as art-rockers deliver their most direct album yetRead More
It's back to the Reagan era and smalltown America in the new sci-fi epic from Netflix. Ed Power binges on the Winona Ryder-starring Stranger Things.Read More
Lorde Acolytes Grow Into Their SoundRead More
Landslide of fun from missing-in-action sample gurusRead More
The comeback kids celebrate their return to Irish shores with a showing every bit as triumphant as 21 years agoRead More
Jamie XX has cast off his shy-boy shackles to become one of the most innovative figures in electronic music.Read More
Up-and-coming Irish rapper Rejjie Snow tells Ed Power about his days as a budding sports star, touring with Madonna and bringing it all back home at Longitude .Read More
Josh Tillman grew up believing in literal hellfire and damnation, he tells Ed Power. As Father John Misty he struggles both with the pain of his pentecostal childhood and the demons of adulthood.Read More
As Netflix’s historical epic Marco Polo returns with a second season, Ed Power talks to star Lorenzo Richelmy about shrugging off bad reviews and why this tale of east meets west resonates with the present day.Read More
Stately concept record from death-obsessed enigma.Read More
NINETIES ICONS KEEP IT SIMPLE WITH MAJESTIC RESULTSRead More
Your favourite prison dramedy is back. Ed Power looks at what we can expect from season four of Netflix’s Orange Is The New Black.Read More
De La Soul have been part of hip hop’s tapestry since the genre exploded in the late ’80s. You could say they have a few stories to tell. Ed Power chats with the amiable Kelvin Mercer about the old days and the new.Read More
The multi-talented Brix Smith Start discusses her new memoir, her old flames and how Princess Diana once flirted with her boyfriend.Read More
Up and coming siren seeks to be all things to all listenersRead More
Top Gear is back but can the new hosts fill the shoes of the previous trio?Read More
Multi-headed jazz crew try to terrify you into liking themRead More
It's the Irish comic book they said could never make it to screen. Now after 20 years and endless speculation, Gareth Ennis's Preacher is finally coming to TV.Read More
DRAKE'S CAREER SERVES AS A CAUTIONARY REMINDER THAT WE SHOULD BE CAREFUL WHAT WE WISH FORRead More
It's ten years since Wolfmother's debut album reinvented heavy, non-ironic rock. In a rare interview,frontman Andrew Stockdale contemplates the album's legacy and explains why nostalgia is ultimately best avoided.Read More
As the Queen twists her stiletto heels into Jay Z's prone midriff, our man Ed Power judges the latest effort from the pop megastar to be her finest work to dateRead More
Cavan singer reaches career high on magnificent third albumRead More
Alt country crooner makes sweet music with Brit chanteuseRead More
CONTROVERSIAL RHYMER DROPS SURPRISE - AND SURPRISINGLY HOT - MIXTAPERead More
Tighten your tabard and sharpen your broadsword – the new Game Of Thrones is almost here. Ed Power consults the Lord of Light, throws a few interns on the pyre, and looks at what we can expect from the world’s favourite TV show.Read More
As they get ready to perform at Dublin's Music Town Festival, limerick hip-hop three-piece talk politics, identity & KanyeRead More
No Doubt front woman pours heartache into frothy comeback record.Read More
After years of buzz, Jack Colleran has just released his first album under his Mmoths moniker. He talks heartache, pressure and the negative stereotyping of lonely boys with laptops.Read More
As they get ready to perform at Dublin's Music Town Festival, the Limerick hip-hop three-piece talk politics, identity & KanyeRead More
With The National off the road, Scott and Bryan Devendorf are indulging their krautrock passion with their new LZNDRFRead More
Santigold’s new album, 99 Cents, may take capitalism to task but it’s also meant to be a fun listen, she tells Ed Power.Read More
Saul that you cant leave behind: Everyone's favourite crooked lawyer is back, as Better Call Saul returns for its second much-anticipated season on Netflix.Read More
Smart R&B from New York pop royaltyRead More
Taylor Swift acolyte finds joy in sadness.Read More
She's a soul sensation to watch - with a gorgeous voice that has already floored Sam Smith. Now the rest of the world is about to discover the sultry sound of Izzy Bizu.Read More
The out-of-nowhere success of Netflix’s Making A Murderer speaks to audiences’ insatiable appetite for true crime. Ed Power dons his detective hat and investigates the making of a television phenomenon.Read More
Acid-fried protest pop lands its punchesRead More
Zany return from psychedelic weirdosRead More
As a teenager she moved to London on her own, determined to break into music. Now Dua Lipa is about to see her wildest dreams come true, with her more-than-meets-the-ear sound set to conquer the charts.Read More
True Detective made director Cary Fukunaga famous. He reflects on the surprise success of the show and talks about putting himself through the grinder shooting his new movie, Beasts Of No NationRead More
Cobain demo collection shows new side to iconic artistRead More
Quirky singer sticks to first principlesRead More
With his mercury-nominated solo album in colour, jamie smith – aka Jamie xx – shows there’s more to the xx than shadows and sulking.Read More
Pop maven releases her catchiest collection yet.Read More
French series The Returned is a zombie lark with a brain – and a distinctly philosophical outlook. As the second series commences, Ed Power examines the show’s international appeal.Read More
Alt-country stalwart unearths Tay-Tay's inner miserabalist.Read More
Dance king-pins Disclosure talk overnight fame, celebrity friends and why Ireland has a special place in their hearts.Read More
Overnight sensation proves shes around for the long haul.Read More
Electro-pop trio come out swinging on second recordRead More
Gobsmacking surprise solo record from Alabama shakes frontwomanRead More
Miley unleashes heartbreaking eulogy to dead dogRead More
He's the falsetto-voiced sensation who has tastemakers in a tizzy. Ladies and gentleman we give you future r&b super star ShamirRead More
Ed Power opines as Bruce Springsteen plays Jon Stewart out.Read More
Zombies are the hottest property on television right now. With hit American show Z Nation arriving on Irish screens this month, Ed Power looks at how the walking – and occasionally running – dead have taken over TV.Read More
Odd Synth Pop from the big new thing of 2009.Read More
Their first album was an overnight phenomenon. Second time around, blues sensations Alabama Shakes are determined to do things on their own terms, they tell Ed Power.Read More
As a new season of hit prison drama Orange Is The New Black debuts on Netflix, Ed Power talks to key cast members and looks at how this quirky show become a surprise sensation.Read More
Young Fathers are intimately acquainted with uproar, having grimaced their way to the Mercury Music Prize and infuriated Gareth Gates. They talk about confronting stereotypes and channelling upheaval into music.Read More
Gloriously eccentric return from Manchester outsidersRead More
Soul man's debut hits the vintage jackpot.Read More
As a new season of hit prison drama Orange Is The New Black debuts on Netflix, Ed Power talks to key cast members – plus series creator Jenji Kohan – and looks at how this quirky show become a surprise sensation.Read More
Series one of True Detective was a creepy blockbuster for the ages. Can the Colin Ferrell-starring second series live up to the crushing weight of expectation?Read More
Were you watching Kanye? On a perfect summer's evening, Mr. Hansen delivered a spell-binding show at the Royal Hospital Kilmainham, Dublin last night.Read More
Digital bliss marks return from Kevin Parker and chumsRead More